Karki Saugat, Shaw Sarah, Lieberman Michael, Pérez Alejandro, Pincus Jonathan, Jakhmola Priya, Tailor Amrita, Ogunrinde Oyinkansola Bukky, Sill Danielle, Morgan Shane, Alvarez Miguel, Todd Jonathan, Smith Dawn, Mishra Ninad
Division of STD Prevention, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, GA, United States.
Public Health Informatics Institute, Decatur, GA, United States.
JMIR Form Res. 2024 Apr 15;8:e53000. doi: 10.2196/53000.
The syndemic nature of gonococcal infections and HIV provides an opportunity to develop a synergistic intervention tool that could address the need for adequate treatment for gonorrhea, screen for HIV infections, and offer pre-exposure prophylaxis (PrEP) for persons who meet the criteria. By leveraging information available on electronic health records, a clinical decision support (CDS) system tool could fulfill this need and improve adherence to Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) treatment and screening guidelines for gonorrhea, HIV, and PrEP.
The goal of this study was to translate portions of CDC treatment guidelines for gonorrhea and relevant portions of HIV screening and prescribing PrEP that stem from a diagnosis of gonorrhea as an electronic health record-based CDS intervention. We also assessed whether this CDS solution worked in real-world clinic.
We developed 4 tools for this CDS intervention: a form for capturing sexual history information (SmartForm), rule-based alerts (best practice advisory), an enhanced sexually transmitted infection (STI) order set (SmartSet), and a documentation template (SmartText). A mixed methods pre-post design was used to measure the feasibility, use, and usability of the CDS solution. The study period was 12 weeks with a baseline patient sample of 12 weeks immediately prior to the intervention period for comparison. While the entire clinic had access to the CDS solution, we focused on a subset of clinicians who frequently engage in the screening and treatment of STIs within the clinical site under the name "X-Clinic." We measured the use of the CDS solution within the population of patients who had either a confirmed gonococcal infection or an STI-related chief complaint. We conducted 4 midpoint surveys and 3 key informant interviews to quantify perception and impact of the CDS solution and solicit suggestions for potential future enhancements. The findings from qualitative data were determined using a combination of explorative and comparative analysis. Statistical analysis was conducted to compare the differences between patient populations in the baseline and intervention periods.
Within the X-Clinic, the CDS alerted clinicians (as a best practice advisory) in one-tenth (348/3451, 10.08%) of clinical encounters. These 348 encounters represented 300 patients; SmartForms were opened for half of these patients (157/300, 52.33%) and was completed for most for them (147/300, 89.81%). STI test orders (SmartSet) were initiated by clinical providers in half of those patients (162/300, 54%). HIV screening was performed during about half of those patient encounters (191/348, 54.89%).
We successfully built and implemented multiple CDC treatment and screening guidelines into a single cohesive CDS solution. The CDS solution was integrated into the clinical workflow and had a high rate of use.
淋病感染与艾滋病毒的共病性质提供了一个机会,可开发一种协同干预工具,满足淋病充分治疗、艾滋病毒感染筛查以及为符合标准者提供暴露前预防(PrEP)的需求。通过利用电子健康记录中的可用信息,临床决策支持(CDS)系统工具可满足这一需求,并提高对疾病控制与预防中心(CDC)淋病、艾滋病毒及PrEP治疗和筛查指南的依从性。
本研究的目标是将CDC淋病治疗指南的部分内容以及基于淋病诊断的艾滋病毒筛查和开具PrEP的相关部分内容转化为基于电子健康记录的CDS干预措施。我们还评估了该CDS解决方案在实际临床环境中的效果。
我们为该CDS干预措施开发了4种工具:用于获取性病史信息的表单(智能表单)、基于规则的警报(最佳实践建议)、增强的性传播感染(STI)医嘱集(智能集)以及文档模板(智能文本)。采用混合方法前后设计来衡量CDS解决方案的可行性、使用情况和可用性。研究期为12周,以干预期前紧挨着的12周患者样本作为基线进行比较。虽然整个诊所都可使用CDS解决方案,但我们重点关注了临床场所内以“X诊所”为名经常从事性传播感染筛查和治疗的一部分临床医生。我们在确诊淋病感染或有性传播感染相关主诉的患者群体中衡量CDS解决方案的使用情况。我们进行了4次中期调查和3次关键信息提供者访谈,以量化对CDS解决方案的认知和影响,并征求未来潜在改进的建议。定性数据的结果通过探索性和比较性分析相结合的方式确定。进行统计分析以比较基线期和干预期患者群体之间的差异。
在X诊所内,CDS(作为最佳实践建议)在十分之一(348/3451,10.08%)的临床诊疗中向临床医生发出警报。这348次诊疗涉及300名患者;其中一半患者(157/300,52.33%)打开了智能表单,且大多数患者(147/300,89.81%)完成了表单填写。临床医生为其中一半患者(162/300,54%)开具了性传播感染检测医嘱(智能集)。在大约一半的患者诊疗过程中(191/348,54.89%)进行了艾滋病毒筛查。
我们成功地将多项CDC治疗和筛查指南构建并实施到一个统一的CDS解决方案中。该CDS解决方案已整合到临床工作流程中,且使用率很高。