Department of Surgery, Western University, London, Ontario, Canada.
Department of Epidemiology and Biostatistics, Western University, London, Ontario, Canada.
J Urol. 2024 Jul;212(1):114-123. doi: 10.1097/JU.0000000000003984. Epub 2024 Apr 16.
Patients with spinal cord injuries (SCIs) experience variable urinary symptoms and quality of life (QOL). Our objective was to use machine learning to identify bladder-relevant phenotypes after SCI and assess their association with urinary symptoms and QOL.
We used data from the Neurogenic Bladder Research Group SCI registry. Baseline variables that were previously shown to be associated with bladder symptoms/QOL were included in the machine learning environment. An unsupervised consensus clustering approach (k-prototypes) was used to identify 4 patient clusters. After qualitative review of the clusters, 2 outcomes of interest were assessed: the total Neurogenic Bladder Symptom Score (NBSS) and the NBSS-satisfaction question (QOL). The NBSS and NBSS-satisfaction question at baseline and after 1 year were compared between clusters using analysis of variance and linear regression.
Among the 1263 included participants, the 4 identified clusters were termed "female predominant," "high function, low SCI complication," "quadriplegia with bowel/bladder morbidity," and "older, high SCI complication." Using outcome data from baseline, significant differences were observed in the NBSS score, with the female predominant group exhibiting worse bladder symptoms. After 1 year, the overall bladder symptoms (NBSS Total) did not change significantly by cluster; however, the QOL score for the high function, low SCI complication group had more improvement (β = -0.12, = .005), while the female predominant group had more deterioration (β = 0.09, = .047).
This study demonstrates the utility of machine learning in uncovering bladder-relevant phenotypes among SCI patients. Future research should explore cluster-based targeted strategies to enhance bladder-related outcomes and QOL in SCI.
脊髓损伤(SCI)患者的尿路症状和生活质量(QOL)存在差异。我们的目的是利用机器学习方法确定 SCI 后与膀胱相关的表型,并评估其与尿路症状和 QOL 的关系。
我们使用了神经原性膀胱研究组 SCI 登记处的数据。纳入了先前与膀胱症状/QOL 相关的基线变量,并将其应用于机器学习环境中。采用无监督共识聚类方法(k-原型)来识别 4 个患者聚类。对聚类进行定性分析后,评估了 2 个感兴趣的结果:总神经原性膀胱症状评分(NBSS)和 NBSS 满意度问题(QOL)。使用方差分析和线性回归比较了基线和 1 年后各聚类之间的 NBSS 和 NBSS 满意度问题。
在纳入的 1263 名参与者中,确定的 4 个聚类分别命名为“女性为主型”、“高功能、低 SCI 并发症型”、“四肢瘫痪伴肠/膀胱发病率型”和“年龄较大、高 SCI 并发症型”。使用基线时的结局数据,NBSS 评分存在显著差异,女性为主型患者的膀胱症状更严重。1 年后,各聚类的总体膀胱症状(NBSS 总分)无明显变化;然而,高功能、低 SCI 并发症型组的 QOL 评分有更多改善(β=-0.12, =.005),而女性为主型组则恶化(β=0.09, =.047)。
本研究证明了机器学习在揭示 SCI 患者与膀胱相关表型方面的有效性。未来的研究应探索基于聚类的靶向策略,以提高 SCI 患者的膀胱相关结局和 QOL。