Krishnan R Anjali, Jithesh Veetilakath, Raj K Vismaya, Fernandez Bhavya Benzigar
Department of Health and Family Welfare, Government of Kerala, Kerala, India.
Indian J Palliat Care. 2024 Jan-Mar;30(1):56-64. doi: 10.25259/IJPC_223_2023. Epub 2024 Feb 16.
Kerala was the first state to implement a community-based, sustainable primary palliative care (PC) home care (HC) model. Beneficiary satisfaction, an important indicator to assess the quality of service provision with the HC program, has not been assessed since the programme was launched 14 years ago. This study tried to assess the satisfaction of beneficiaries receiving primary PC services through the Kerala State PC programme and the factors associated with the same.
The cross-sectional survey was conducted among 450 patients registered under the Kerala State Primary PC Programme. Data were collected using a semi-structured questionnaire from October 2022 to January 2023. We summarised the data as proportions and performed Chi-square tests to make comparisons wherever applicable.
Most of the beneficiaries (69.1%) were satisfied with HC services. The mean age of the beneficiaries was 65.51 ± 17 years. More than 80% of the participants (88.4%) were married, and the primary caregivers were wives (31.8%) and daughters/daughters-in-law (35.3%). The primary diagnosis of the beneficiaries was a cerebrovascular accident (27.4%), cancer (18.8%), and spinal cord injury (13.2%). The study examined the needs of beneficiaries and found that the top three requirements reported by the patients were the inclusion of doctor visits in HC (71.8%), medicine distribution at home (67.4%), and physical rehabilitation services at home with a minimum of three sessions per month (52.3%). The study found a statistically significant association ( < 0.05) between the Beneficiary's satisfaction and behaviour of PC nurses and certain services, including physiotherapy, procedural care specifically catheterisation and wound dressing, and health check-ups received through the HC program. Satisfaction was reported more in Thiruvananthapuram district, followed by Malappuram.
The overall satisfaction with the Kerala State Primary PC Programme was found to be high at about 69%. Despite the fact that the study identified significant relationships between nurses' behaviour, services provided (physical therapy, procedures, and health checks), and satisfaction, the findings suggested expanding the scope of the HC programme by including doctor visits and medicine delivery at patient's home.
喀拉拉邦是首个实施基于社区的可持续初级姑息治疗(PC)家庭护理(HC)模式的邦。受益人的满意度是评估家庭护理项目服务质量的一项重要指标,自该项目在14年前启动以来,尚未对此进行过评估。本研究试图评估通过喀拉拉邦初级姑息治疗项目接受初级姑息治疗服务的受益人的满意度及其相关因素。
对喀拉拉邦初级姑息治疗项目登记的450名患者进行了横断面调查。2022年10月至2023年1月,使用半结构化问卷收集数据。我们将数据汇总为比例,并在适用时进行卡方检验以进行比较。
大多数受益人(69.1%)对家庭护理服务感到满意。受益人的平均年龄为65.51±17岁。超过80%的参与者(88.4%)已婚,主要照顾者为妻子(31.8%)和女儿/儿媳(35.3%)。受益人的主要诊断为脑血管意外(27.4%)、癌症(18.8%)和脊髓损伤(13.2%)。该研究调查了受益人的需求,发现患者报告的前三大需求是将医生上门问诊纳入家庭护理(71.8%)、送药上门(67.4%)以及每月至少三次的家庭物理康复服务(52.3%)。研究发现,受益人满意度与姑息治疗护士的行为以及某些服务之间存在统计学显著关联(<0.05),这些服务包括物理治疗、特定的操作护理(如导尿和伤口换药)以及通过家庭护理项目接受的健康检查。据报告,特里凡得琅区的满意度更高,其次是马拉普拉姆。
喀拉拉邦初级姑息治疗项目的总体满意度较高,约为69%。尽管该研究确定了护士行为、提供的服务(物理治疗、操作和健康检查)与满意度之间存在显著关系,但研究结果表明,应通过将医生上门问诊和送药上门纳入家庭护理项目来扩大其范围。