Hospital Necker Enfants Malades, Paris, France.
Eur Arch Otorhinolaryngol. 2024 Sep;281(9):4649-4655. doi: 10.1007/s00405-024-08658-1. Epub 2024 Apr 20.
Videos and images are becoming an educational tool in every domain. The objective was to assess the contribution of short educational endoscopic videos in learning the complex anatomy of the tympanic cavity.
We conducted a prospective study amongst all the otolaryngology residents in 2021 in the greater Paris area (n = 74), from the first year to fifth year. We divided the residents into two groups who had the same 30-min anatomy class based on anatomical drawings. The second group had a 4-min endoscopic educational video at the end, whereas the first group did not. A video test of 10 surgical situations with each time 5 anatomic structures to identify was created. All the residents took the test just after the class, and 1 month later to assess long-term memory. The MERSQI score (design to assess the quality of educational studies) applied to our study was calculated.
The two groups were comparable in terms of training. The "video" group had significantly better results in the first test, mean score 24.40/50 (± 11.7) versus 16.74/50 (± 11.1) (p = 0.005) and also at 1 month, mean score 23.25/50 (± 12.3) versus 18.01/50 (± 11.3) (p = 0.035). The score in each group, and the difference between both groups, increased with resident seniority. The MERSQI score of our study was 14.5/18.
This study highlights the educational value of videos to help memorise complex 3D anatomy such as in the tympanic cavity.
视频和图像正在成为各个领域的教育工具。本研究旨在评估短期内镜教育视频在学习鼓室复杂解剖结构中的作用。
我们在 2021 年对大巴黎地区的所有耳鼻喉科住院医师(n=74)进行了一项前瞻性研究,他们分为第一年到第五年的各个年级。我们将住院医师分为两组,两组都参加了基于解剖图的 30 分钟解剖课程。第二组在课程结束时观看 4 分钟内镜教育视频,而第一组则不观看。我们创建了一个包含 10 种手术情况的视频测试,每次测试有 5 个解剖结构需要识别。所有住院医师在课后立即参加测试,并在 1 个月后再次参加测试以评估长期记忆。我们计算了适用于我们研究的 MERSQI 评分(用于评估教育研究质量的评分)。
两组在培训方面具有可比性。“视频”组在第一次测试中的成绩明显更好,平均得分为 24.40/50(±11.7),而第一组得分为 16.74/50(±11.1)(p=0.005),在 1 个月后再次测试时,“视频”组的平均得分为 23.25/50(±12.3),而第一组的平均得分为 18.01/50(±11.3)(p=0.035)。每个组的分数以及两个组之间的差异都随着住院医师的资历增加而增加。我们研究的 MERSQI 评分为 14.5/18。
本研究强调了视频在帮助记忆复杂 3D 解剖结构(如鼓室)方面的教育价值。