Boston University School of Social Work, 264 Bay State Road, Boston, MA, 02215, USA.
Department of Psychiatry, Boston Medical Center Crosstown Center, 4th Floor 801 Massachusetts Avenue, 02118, Boston, MA, USA.
Harm Reduct J. 2024 Apr 20;21(1):83. doi: 10.1186/s12954-024-01002-0.
Recovery from addiction is frequently equated with abstinence. However, some individuals who resolve an addiction continue to use substances, including via substitution (i.e., increased use of one substance after eliminating/ reducing another). Substitution may play a distinct role during early recovery (≤ 1 year), as this period is marked by dramatic change and adjustment. Cannabis is one of the most used substances and is legal for medical and recreational use in an increasing number of states. Consequently, cannabis an increasingly accessible substitute for substances, like fentanyl, heroin, cocaine and methamphetamine, with higher risk profiles (e.g., associated with risk for withdrawal, overdose, and incarceration).
Fourteen participants reported that they had resolved a primary opioid or stimulant addiction and subsequently increased their cannabis use within the previous 12 months. Using grounded theory, the interviewer explored their experiences of cannabis use during early recovery. Data were analyzed in three stages: line by line coding for all text related to cannabis use and recovery, focused coding, and axial coding to generate a theory about recovery with cannabis substitution. The motivational model of substance use provided sensitizing concepts.
RESULTS & DISCUSSION: The final sample included eight men and six women ranging in age from 20 to 50 years old. Three participants resolved an addiction to methamphetamine and the remaining 11, an addiction to opioids. Participants explained that cannabis was appealing because of its less harmful profile (e.g., no overdose risk, safe supply, few side effects). Participants' primary motives for cannabis use included mitigation of psychiatric symptoms, withdrawal/ cravings, and boredom. While cannabis was effective toward these ends, participants also reported some negative side effects (e.g., decreased productivity, social anxiety). All participants described typical benefits of recovery (e.g., improved self-concept, better relationships) while continuing to use cannabis. Their experiences with and beliefs about substitution suggest it can be an effective strategy for some individuals during early recovery.
Cannabis use may benefit some adults who are reducing their opioid or stimulant use, especially during early recovery. The addiction field's focus on abstinence has limited our knowledge about non-abstinent recovery. Longitudinal studies are needed to understand the nature of substitution and its impact on recovery over time.
成瘾的康复通常等同于戒除。然而,一些解决成瘾问题的人继续使用物质,包括通过替代(即在消除/减少另一种物质后增加使用一种物质)。替代可能在早期康复(≤1 年)期间发挥独特的作用,因为这一时期标志着剧烈的变化和调整。大麻是使用最广泛的物质之一,在越来越多的州,大麻被用于医疗和娱乐目的。因此,大麻成为芬太尼、海洛因、可卡因和冰毒等风险较高的物质的一种越来越容易获得的替代品(例如,与戒断、过量和监禁风险相关)。
14 名参与者报告说,他们已经解决了主要的阿片类或兴奋剂成瘾问题,并在过去 12 个月内增加了大麻的使用。使用扎根理论,采访者探讨了他们在早期康复期间使用大麻的经验。数据分三个阶段进行分析:对所有与大麻使用和康复相关的文本进行逐行编码、聚焦编码和轴向编码,以生成关于大麻替代康复的理论。物质使用的动机模型提供了敏感概念。
最终样本包括 8 名男性和 6 名女性,年龄在 20 岁至 50 岁之间。3 名参与者解决了冰毒成瘾问题,其余 11 名参与者解决了阿片类药物成瘾问题。参与者解释说,大麻之所以吸引人,是因为它的危害较小(例如,没有过量风险、安全供应、很少有副作用)。参与者使用大麻的主要动机包括减轻精神症状、戒断/渴望和无聊。虽然大麻在这些方面有效,但参与者也报告了一些负面影响(例如,生产力下降、社交焦虑)。所有参与者都描述了康复的典型好处(例如,自我概念改善、更好的人际关系),同时继续使用大麻。他们对替代的经验和信念表明,在早期康复期间,替代可能对一些人有效。
大麻的使用可能对一些减少阿片类或兴奋剂使用的成年人有益,尤其是在早期康复期间。成瘾领域对禁欲的关注限制了我们对非禁欲康复的了解。需要进行纵向研究,以了解替代的性质及其对随时间恢复的影响。