Sui Zhining, Wang Qinyan, Xu Jing
Department of Biostatistics, University of Washington, 1410 NE Campus Parkway, Seattle, WA, 98195, USA.
Department of Biostatistics and Computational Biology, University of Rochester, 265 Crittenden Boulevard, Rochester, NY, 14642, USA.
Sci Rep. 2024 Apr 21;14(1):9140. doi: 10.1038/s41598-024-59985-6.
A core issue in the interdisciplinary study of human morality is its ontogeny in diverse cultures, but systematic, naturalistic data in specific cultural contexts are rare to find. This study conducts a novel analysis of 213 children's socio-moral behavior in a historical, non-Western, rural setting, based on a unique dataset of naturalistic observations from the first field research on Han Chinese children. Using multilevel multinomial modeling, we examined a range of proactive behaviors in 0-to-12-year-old children's peer cooperation and conflict in an entire community in postwar Taiwan. We modeled the effects of age, sex, kinship, and behavioral roles, and revealed complex interactions between these four variables in shaping children's moral development. We discovered linkages between coercive and non-coercive behaviors as children strategically negotiated leadership dynamics. We identified connections between prosocial and aggressive behaviors, illuminating the nuances of morality in real life. Our analysis also revealed gendered patterns and age-related trends that deviated from cultural norms and contradicted popular assumptions about Chinese family values. These findings highlight the importance of naturalistic observations in cultural contexts for understanding how we become moral persons. This re-analysis of historically significant fieldnotes also enriches the interdisciplinary study of child development across societies.
人类道德跨学科研究中的一个核心问题是其在不同文化中的个体发展过程,但在特定文化背景下的系统、自然主义数据却很难找到。本研究基于对中国汉族儿童首次实地研究的独特自然主义观察数据集,对历史上一个非西方农村环境中213名儿童的社会道德行为进行了新颖的分析。我们使用多层次多项模型,研究了战后台湾一个完整社区中0至12岁儿童在同伴合作与冲突中的一系列积极行为。我们对年龄、性别、亲属关系和行为角色的影响进行了建模,并揭示了这四个变量在塑造儿童道德发展过程中的复杂相互作用。我们发现,随着儿童战略性地协商领导动态,强制行为和非强制行为之间存在联系。我们确定了亲社会行为和攻击行为之间的关联,阐明了现实生活中道德的细微差别。我们的分析还揭示了与文化规范相悖且与关于中国家庭价值观的普遍假设相矛盾的性别模式和与年龄相关的趋势。这些发现凸显了在文化背景下进行自然主义观察对于理解我们如何成为有道德的人的重要性。对具有历史意义的实地记录的重新分析也丰富了跨社会儿童发展的跨学科研究。