Roitberg Bernard, Li Chao, Lalonde Robert
Department of BioScience, Simon Fraser University, Burnaby, BC, Canada.
Canadian Wood Fibre Centre, Canadian Forest Service, Edmonton, AB, Canada.
Front Plant Sci. 2024 Feb 26;15:1344883. doi: 10.3389/fpls.2024.1344883. eCollection 2024.
Understanding stand dynamics is essential for predicting future wood supply and associated ecosystem services for sustainable forest management. The dynamics of natural stands can be characterized by age-dependent growth and yield models. However, dynamics in managed stands appear somewhat different from that of natural stands, especially with difficulties in explaining the phenomenon of post-thinning overcompensation, based upon some long-term observations. Though overcompensation is an ideal outcome for the forest sector, it had been largely treated as an outlier and thus ignored or dismissed as "out-of-the-ordinary".
We developed a life history theory-based, state-dependent model of Tree Adaptive Growth (TAG) to investigate this phenomenon and verified that overcompensation should be a common outcome in post-thinning forest stands when the stand growth over time is sigmoid shaped. TAG posits that individual trees will invest proportionately more into growth following thinning because it is evolutionarily adaptive to do so.
Our investigation of the model's behavior unearthed diverse stand growth patterns similar to that which is observed in the empirical datasets and predicted by a statistics-based Tree's Compensatory Growth (TreeCG) model.
A simple, theory-driven, analytical model, TAG, can reproduce the diverse growth patterns in post-thinning stands and thus assist addressing silviculture-related issues. The model can be applied to various jurisdictions even without detailed regional growth and yield relationships and is capable of incorporating the effects of other time sensitive factors like fertilization, pruning, and climate change.
了解林分动态对于预测未来木材供应及相关生态系统服务以实现可持续森林管理至关重要。天然林分的动态可以通过年龄依赖型生长和产量模型来表征。然而,人工林分的动态似乎与天然林分有所不同,特别是基于一些长期观测结果,难以解释间伐后超补偿现象。尽管超补偿对林业部门来说是一个理想的结果,但它在很大程度上被视为异常值,因此被忽视或当作“不寻常”情况而不予考虑。
我们开发了一种基于生活史理论的、状态依赖型的树木适应性生长(TAG)模型来研究这一现象,并验证了当林分随时间的生长呈S形时,超补偿应该是间伐后林分的常见结果。TAG模型假定,间伐后个体树木会按比例将更多资源投入到生长中,因为这样做在进化上是适应性的。
我们对该模型行为的研究发现了多种林分生长模式,类似于在实证数据集中观察到的以及基于统计的树木补偿生长(TreeCG)模型所预测的模式。
一个简单的、理论驱动的分析模型TAG能够再现间伐后林分的多种生长模式,从而有助于解决与造林学相关的问题。该模型甚至可以应用于不同的地区,而无需详细的区域生长和产量关系,并且能够纳入施肥、修剪和气候变化等其他时间敏感因素的影响。