During an infection, innate immune cells must adjust nature and strength of their responses to changing pathogen abundances. To determine how stimulation of the pathogen sensing TLR4 shapes subsequent macrophage responses, we systematically varied priming and restimulation concentrations of its ligand KLA. We find that different priming strengths have very distinct effects at multiple stages of the signaling response, including receptor internalization, MAPK activation, cytokine and chemokine production, and nuclear translocation and chromatin association of NFκB and IκB members. In particular, restimulation-induced TNF-α production required KLA doses equal to or greater than those used for prior exposure, indicating that macrophages can detect and adaptively respond to changing TLR4 stimuli. Interestingly, while such adaptation was dependent on the anti-inflammatory cytokine IL-10, exogenous concentrations of IL-10 corresponding to those secreted after strong priming did not exert suppressive effects on TNF-α without such prior priming, confirming the critical role of TLR4 stimulation history.