Cho Hyunjin, Kang Kyewon, Kang Hamin, Jeon Seoyoung, Lee Mingyung, Park Eunkyu, Hong Seokman, Seo Seongwon
Division of Animal and Dairy Sciences, Chungnam National University, Daejeon 34134, Korea.
Woosung Feed Co., Ltd., Daejeon 34379, Korea.
Anim Biosci. 2024 Sep;37(9):1568-1580. doi: 10.5713/ab.24.0074. Epub 2024 Apr 25.
This study investigated the repeatability of feed efficiency and its association with carcass traits in Hanwoo steers during the entire growing and fattening periods.
The growth and intake of thirty-six Hanwoo steers (259±19.7 kg; nine months) were monitored throughout five periods, including two growing periods (GP) and three fattening periods (FP). The steers were fed two types of concentrate mixes with varying nutrient compositions until they reached a target weight of 800 kg for slaughter. For each period, steers were categorized into three classes based on their feed efficiency rankings using residual feed intake (RFI) and feed conversion ratio (FCR). Feed efficiency repeatability was assessed using the Spearman correlation coefficient, decomposition of random errors, and the Theil segregation index (TSI). The Pearson correlation coefficient was used to examine the relationship between feed efficiency and carcass traits.
The results demonstrated a significant and high correlation with RFI, but not FCR, during the growing or fattening stages (r>0.5; p<0.01). When steers were classified according to their feed efficiency rankings, 58% of the animals in the high RFI class (low efficient) initially (GP 1) remained in the same class by the last period (FP 3), whereas steers were randomly distributed based on FCR. The repeatability, assessed by the decomposition of random errors, was higher for RFI (0.61) than for FCR (0.15). The TSI also indicated that RFI rankings, rather than FCR rankings, are more likely to be maintained. Moreover, a weak association was observed between feed efficiency and carcass traits.
In conclusion, RFI repeatability throughout the GP and FP surpassed that of the FCR, with steers classified as high RFI during the GP more likely to remain in the same class during the FP. Feed efficiency was weakly correlated with carcass traits.
本研究调查了韩牛公牛在整个生长育肥期饲料效率的重复性及其与胴体性状的关联。
在包括两个生长阶段(GP)和三个育肥阶段(FP)的五个阶段中,对36头韩牛公牛(体重259±19.7千克;9月龄)的生长和采食量进行监测。给这些公牛饲喂两种营养成分不同的精料混合料,直至达到800千克的屠宰目标体重。在每个阶段,根据剩余采食量(RFI)和饲料转化率(FCR)将公牛按饲料效率排名分为三类。使用斯皮尔曼相关系数、随机误差分解和泰尔分离指数(TSI)评估饲料效率的重复性。使用皮尔逊相关系数检验饲料效率与胴体性状之间的关系。
结果表明,在生长或育肥阶段,RFI存在显著且高度的相关性,但FCR不存在(r>0.5;p<0.01)。当根据饲料效率排名对公牛进行分类时,高RFI类(低效)中58%的动物在最初阶段(GP 1)到最后阶段(FP 3)仍处于同一类别,而根据FCR分类时公牛是随机分布的。通过随机误差分解评估的重复性,RFI(0.61)高于FCR(0.15)。TSI也表明,RFI排名比FCR排名更有可能保持。此外,在饲料效率与胴体性状之间观察到较弱的关联。
总之,在整个生长阶段和育肥阶段,RFI的重复性超过FCR,在生长阶段被归类为高RFI的公牛在育肥阶段更有可能保持在同一类别。饲料效率与胴体性状的相关性较弱。