Centre for Sustainable Healthcare, Oxford, UK.
Trinity College Dublin, Dublin, Ireland.
Eur Arch Paediatr Dent. 2024 Jun;25(3):393-408. doi: 10.1007/s40368-024-00895-6. Epub 2024 Apr 28.
This paper reports a life cycle impact assessment (LCIA) to calculate the environmental footprint of a dental appointment using NO, comparing single-use equipment with reusable equipment. Nitrous oxide (NO) is used successfully in dentistry to provide sedation and pain relief to anxious patients, most commonly in children. However, NO is a powerful climate pollutant 298 times more damaging than carbon dioxide over a 100-year estimate.
The functional unit chosen for this LCIA was 30 min delivery of NO to oxygen in a 50:50 ratio at 6 L per minute flow rate as inhalation sedation to one patient. Two types of equipment were compared to deliver the anaesthetic gas: reusable and disposable items.
The use of disposable equipment for NO sedation produces a significantly larger environmental impact across nearly all of the environmental impact scores, but the overall global warming potential is comparable for both types of equipment due to the vast environmental pollution from NO itself.
NO sedation is a reliable treatment adjunct but contributes to climate change. Single-use equipment has a further deleterious effect on the environment, though this is small compared to the overall impact of NO. Dental priorities should be to deliver safe and effective care to patients that protects staff, minimises waste and mitigates impact on the environment alongside promoting research into alternatives.
本研究报告了一项生命周期影响评估(LCIA),旨在计算使用一氧化二氮(NO)进行牙科预约的环境足迹,比较一次性设备和可重复使用设备。一氧化二氮(NO)在牙科中成功用于为焦虑患者提供镇静和缓解疼痛,最常见于儿童。然而,NO 是一种强大的气候污染物,在 100 年的估计中,其对气候的破坏是二氧化碳的 298 倍。
本 LCIA 选择的功能单位为 30 分钟内以 6 升/分钟的流速将 50:50 比例的 NO 输送到氧气中,为一名患者提供吸入镇静。比较了两种设备来输送麻醉气体:可重复使用和一次性设备。
使用一次性设备进行 NO 镇静在几乎所有环境影响评分方面都会产生更大的环境影响,但由于 NO 本身造成的巨大环境污染,两种设备的总全球变暖潜力相当。
NO 镇静是一种可靠的治疗辅助手段,但会导致气候变化。一次性设备对环境的进一步有害影响虽然与 NO 的总体影响相比很小,但仍应优先考虑为患者提供安全有效的护理,保护工作人员,减少浪费,并减轻对环境的影响,同时促进替代方案的研究。