Department of Adult Intensive Care, Erasmus Medical Centre, Rotterdam, The Netherlands.
Department of Neonatal and Pediatric Intensive Care, Erasmus Medical Centre-Sophia Children's Hospital, Rotterdam, The Netherlands.
Physiol Meas. 2024 May 21;45(5). doi: 10.1088/1361-6579/ad46e3.
Electrical impedance tomography (EIT) produces clinical useful visualization of the distribution of ventilation inside the lungs. The accuracy of EIT-derived parameters can be compromised by the cardiovascular signal. Removal of these artefacts is challenging due to spectral overlapping of the ventilatory and cardiovascular signal components and their time-varying frequencies. We designed and evaluated advanced filtering techniques and hypothesized that these would outperform traditional low-pass filters.Three filter techniques were developed and compared against traditional low-pass filtering: multiple digital notch filtering (MDN), empirical mode decomposition (EMD) and the maximal overlap discrete wavelet transform (MODWT). The performance of the filtering techniques was evaluated (1) in the time domain (2) in the frequency domain (3) by visual inspection. We evaluated the performance using simulated contaminated EIT data and data from 15 adult and neonatal intensive care unit patients.Each filter technique exhibited varying degrees of effectiveness and limitations. Quality measures in the time domain showed the best performance for MDN filtering. The signal to noise ratio was best for DLP, but at the cost of a high relative and removal error. MDN outbalanced the performance resulting in a good SNR with a low relative and removal error. MDN, EMD and MODWT performed similar in the frequency domain and were successful in removing the high frequency components of the data.Advanced filtering techniques have benefits compared to traditional filters but are not always better. MDN filtering outperformed EMD and MODWT regarding quality measures in the time domain. This study emphasizes the need for careful consideration when choosing a filtering approach, depending on the dataset and the clinical/research question.
电阻抗断层成像(EIT)可产生肺部通气分布的临床有用可视化效果。EIT 衍生参数的准确性可能会受到心血管信号的影响。由于通气和心血管信号成分及其随时间变化的频率的光谱重叠,去除这些伪影具有挑战性。我们设计并评估了先进的滤波技术,并假设这些技术将优于传统的低通滤波器。
多数字陷波滤波(MDN)、经验模态分解(EMD)和最大重叠离散小波变换(MODWT)。通过(1)时域、(2)频域和(3)视觉检查评估了过滤技术的性能。我们使用模拟污染 EIT 数据和来自 15 名成人和新生儿重症监护病房患者的数据评估了性能。
每种过滤技术都表现出不同程度的有效性和局限性。时域中的质量度量显示 MDN 滤波的性能最佳。DLP 的信噪比最佳,但代价是相对和去除误差高。MDN 平衡了性能,从而具有低相对和去除误差的良好 SNR。MDN、EMD 和 MODWT 在频域中的性能相似,并且成功地去除了数据的高频成分。
与传统滤波器相比,先进的滤波技术具有优势,但并不总是更好。MDN 滤波在时域中的质量度量方面优于 EMD 和 MODWT。这项研究强调了在选择过滤方法时需要根据数据集和临床/研究问题进行仔细考虑。