Hanscheid Thomas, Del Portal Luyten Claire Ruiz, Hermans Sabine M, Grobusch Martin P
Instituto de Microbiologia, Faculdade de Medicina, Universidade de Lisboa, Lisbon, Portugal.
Center for Tropical Medicine and Travel Medicine, Department of Infectious Diseases, Amsterdam Infection and Immunity, Amsterdam Public Health, Amsterdam UMC, Location University of Amsterdam, Meibergdreef 9, 1105 AZ, Amsterdam, Netherlands.
Malar J. 2024 May 3;23(1):132. doi: 10.1186/s12936-024-04967-2.
Drug repurposing offers a strategic alternative to the development of novel compounds, leveraging the known safety and pharmacokinetic profiles of medications, such as linezolid and levofloxacin for tuberculosis (TB). Anti-malarial drugs, including quinolones and artemisinins, are already applied to other diseases and infections and could be promising for TB treatment.
This review included studies on the activity of anti-malarial drugs, specifically quinolones and artemisinins, against Mycobacterium tuberculosis complex (MTC), summarizing results from in vitro, in vivo (animal models) studies, and clinical trials. Studies on drugs not primarily developed for TB (doxycycline, sulfonamides) and any novel developed compounds were excluded. Analysis focused on in vitro activity (minimal inhibitory concentrations), synergistic effects, pre-clinical activity, and clinical trials.
Nineteen studies, including one ongoing Phase 1 clinical trial, were analysed: primarily investigating quinolones like mefloquine and chloroquine, and, to a lesser extent, artemisinins. In vitro findings revealed high MIC values for anti-malarials versus standard TB drugs, suggesting a limited activity. Synergistic effects with anti-TB drugs were modest, with some synergy observed in combinations with isoniazid or pyrazinamide. In vivo animal studies showed limited activity of anti-malarials against MTC, except for one study of the combination of chloroquine with isoniazid.
The repurposing of anti-malarials for TB treatment is limited by high MIC values, poor synergy, and minimal in vivo effects. Concerns about potential toxicity at effective dosages and the risk of antimicrobial resistance, especially where TB and malaria overlap, further question their repurposing. These findings suggest that focusing on novel compounds might be both more beneficial and rewarding.
药物重新利用为新型化合物的开发提供了一种战略选择,利用了已知药物的安全性和药代动力学特征,如用于治疗结核病(TB)的利奈唑胺和左氧氟沙星。包括喹诺酮类和青蒿素类在内的抗疟药物已被应用于其他疾病和感染,可能对结核病治疗有前景。
本综述纳入了关于抗疟药物,特别是喹诺酮类和青蒿素类对结核分枝杆菌复合群(MTC)活性的研究,总结了体外、体内(动物模型)研究和临床试验的结果。排除了主要不是为结核病开发的药物(多西环素、磺胺类)和任何新开发的化合物的研究。分析重点在于体外活性(最低抑菌浓度)、协同作用、临床前活性和临床试验。
分析了19项研究,包括一项正在进行的1期临床试验:主要研究喹诺酮类如甲氟喹和氯喹,其次是青蒿素类。体外研究结果显示,抗疟药物相对于标准结核病药物的最低抑菌浓度值较高,表明活性有限。与抗结核药物的协同作用适中,与异烟肼或吡嗪酰胺联合使用时观察到一些协同作用。体内动物研究表明,除了一项氯喹与异烟肼联合使用的研究外,抗疟药物对MTC的活性有限。
抗疟药物用于结核病治疗受到最低抑菌浓度值高、协同作用差和体内效果微小的限制。对有效剂量下潜在毒性以及抗菌药物耐药性风险的担忧,特别是在结核病和疟疾重叠的地区,进一步质疑了它们的重新利用。这些发现表明,专注于新型化合物可能更有益且更有价值。