Budiarto Rahmat, Adli Danung Nur, Wahyono Teguh, Ujilestari Tri, Sholikin Mohammad Miftakhus, Mubarok Syariful, Sari Dwi Novanda, Khalisha Ana, Sari Stefina Liana, Abdullakasim Supatida
Department of Agronomy, Faculty of Agriculture, Universitas Padjadjaran, Sumedang 45363, Indonesia.
Meta-Analysis in Plant Science (MAPS) Research Group, Bandung 40621, Indonesia.
MethodsX. 2024 May 3;12:102742. doi: 10.1016/j.mex.2024.102742. eCollection 2024 Jun.
The present work disseminates a solid scientific meta-analysis method to investigate the impact of storage duration and temperature on vitamin C of citrus. This work is initiated by designing of the PICO framework, collecting, and organizing the articles, creating selection criteria, sorting articles, identifying factors influencing moderation effects and sources of diversity, tabulating data, and employing analysis in the form of a linear mixed model. Using this method, we identified 54 distinct studies from a pool of 289 eligible peer-reviewed publications, focusing on variations of vitamin C in citrus. The method provides mean values in both quadratic and linear regression forms.•This method provides a detailed description starting from topic selection to statistical methodologies intended for performing meta-analysis.•All guidelines for conducting this method have been approved by all authors and adhere to the standard PRISMA-P guidelines.•Disseminating this method in a peer-reviewed publication aims to facilitate scholarly discussions and promote transparency, ultimately improving the standard for performing meta-analysis on vitamin C levels in citrus concerning various genotypes, storage temperatures, and durations.
本研究传播了一种可靠的科学荟萃分析方法，以调查储存时间和温度对柑橘类水果维生素C的影响。这项工作始于设计PICO框架、收集和整理文章、制定选择标准、筛选文章、确定影响调节效应的因素和多样性来源、将数据制成表格，以及采用线性混合模型形式进行分析。使用这种方法，我们从289篇符合条件的同行评审出版物中筛选出54项不同的研究，重点关注柑橘类水果中维生素C的变化。该方法以二次回归和线性回归形式提供均值。•该方法提供了从主题选择到用于进行荟萃分析的统计方法的详细描述。•进行此方法的所有指南均已得到所有作者的批准，并遵循标准的PRISMA-P指南。•在同行评审出版物中传播此方法旨在促进学术讨论并提高透明度，最终提高针对不同基因型、储存温度和持续时间对柑橘类水果维生素C水平进行荟萃分析的标准。
