Leslie Dan Faculty of Pharmacy, University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada.
Amsterdam Law School, University of Amsterdam, Amsterdam, Netherlands.
Glob Public Health. 2024 Jan;19(1):2350649. doi: 10.1080/17441692.2024.2350649. Epub 2024 May 16.
Pharmaceutical sector corruption undermines patient access to medicines by diverting public funds for private gain and exacerbating health inequities This paper presents an analysis of (UNCAC) compliance in seven countries and examines how full UNCAC adoption may reduce corruption risks within four key pharmaceutical decision-making points: product approval, formulary selection, procurement, and dispensing. Countries were selected based on their participation in the Medicines Transparency Alliance and the WHO Good Governance for Medicines Programme. Each country's domestic anti-corruption laws and policies were catalogued and analysed to evaluate their implementation of select UNCAC Articles relevant to the pharmaceutical sector. Countries displayed high compliance with UNCAC provisions on procurement and the recognition of most public sector corruption offences. However, several countries do not penalise private sector bribery or provide statutory protection to whistleblowers or witnesses in corruption proceedings, suggesting that private sector pharmaceutical dispensing may be a decision-making point particularly vulnerable to corruption. Fully implementing the UNCAC is a meaningful first step that countries can take reduce pharmaceutical sector corruption. However, without broader commitment to cultures of transparency and institutional integrity, corruption legislation alone is likely insufficient to ensure long-term, sustainable pharmaceutical sector good governance.
制药行业腐败通过将公共资金用于私人利益转移,从而破坏患者获得药品的机会,并加剧卫生不平等。本文分析了七个国家在《联合国反腐败公约》(UNCAC)方面的合规情况,并探讨了全面采用《联合国反腐败公约》可能如何降低四个关键制药决策点(产品批准、目录选择、采购和配药)的腐败风险。选择这些国家的依据是它们参与了药品透明度联盟和世界卫生组织药品良好治理方案。对每个国家的国内反腐败法律和政策进行了编目和分析,以评估其在与制药部门相关的《联合国反腐败公约》部分条款方面的执行情况。各国在采购和承认大多数公共部门腐败罪行方面高度遵守《联合国反腐败公约》的规定。然而,一些国家不处罚私营部门贿赂行为,也不为腐败诉讼中的举报者或证人提供法定保护,这表明私营部门的药品配药可能是一个特别容易受到腐败影响的决策点。全面执行《联合国反腐败公约》是各国可以采取的减少制药行业腐败的有意义的第一步。然而,如果没有更广泛地致力于透明和机构完整性文化,仅仅依靠反腐败立法可能不足以确保长期、可持续的制药部门良好治理。