Flottes Yohann, Porcherot Audrey, Berteretche Marie-Violaine, Citterio Hélène, Fromentin Olivier, Rignon-Bret Christophe, Braud Adeline, Wulfman Claudine
Int J Prosthodont. 2025 Jul 22;38(4):437-447. doi: 10.11607/ijp.9022.
To determine whether digital training improves conceptual skills acquisition for custom tray fabrication and tooth arrangement in the preclinical curriculum for complete denture fabrication.
A crossover design study compared third-year student grades after conventional (manual) and digital training. Half the students were trained with conventional techniques prior to digital, while the other half were trained with digital techniques prior to conventional. The first part of the study (DP1) focused on custom tray fabrication and involved 154 students. The second part (DP2) focused on tooth arrangement with 204 students. The effect of preliminary digital training on conceptual skills was assessed by comparing the results of the students using Student t test. Results were also analyzed by ranking the students' Perceptual Ability Test (PAT) score. Finally, students' satisfaction with the training was investigated.
Students who completed the initial digital session achieved better custom tray fabrication and tooth arrangement in the subsequent manual sessions. For manual laboratory work, the most dexterous students (PAT1 group) demonstrated the best performance. However, PAT2 students had the best performance during the digital sessions during DP1, and PAT1 and PAT2 students had the best performance during the digital sessions during DP2. Additionally, 40% of DP1 and 12% of DP2 students expressed satisfaction with digital sessions.
With complementary manual and digital teaching, digital tools may be useful for enhanced student learning. Digital training has contributed to improved results in manual sessions but did not affect student satisfaction and remained a limited tool to detect learning difficulties.
确定在全口义齿制作临床前课程中,数字化培训是否能提高定制托盘制作和排牙的概念性技能获取。
一项交叉设计研究比较了传统(手工)培训和数字化培训后三年级学生的成绩。一半学生先接受传统技术培训,再接受数字化培训,而另一半学生先接受数字化技术培训,再接受传统培训。研究的第一部分(DP1)聚焦于定制托盘制作,涉及154名学生。第二部分(DP2)聚焦于排牙,有204名学生参与。通过使用学生t检验比较学生的结果,评估初步数字化培训对概念性技能的影响。结果还通过对学生的感知能力测试(PAT)分数进行排名来分析。最后,调查了学生对培训的满意度。
完成初始数字化课程的学生在随后的手工课程中定制托盘制作和排牙表现更好。对于手工实验室工作,最灵巧的学生(PAT1组)表现最佳。然而,在DP1期间的数字化课程中,PAT2学生表现最佳,在DP2期间的数字化课程中,PAT1和PAT2学生表现最佳。此外,40%的DP1学生和12%的DP2学生对数字化课程表示满意。
通过手工和数字化教学互补,数字化工具可能有助于提高学生的学习效果。数字化培训有助于提高手工课程的成绩,但不影响学生满意度,并且仍然是检测学习困难的有限工具。