Porcherot Audrey, Maniani Imane, Berteretche Marie-Violaine, Citterio Hélène, Fromentin Olivier, Rignon-Bret Christophe, Braud Adeline, Wulfman Claudine
Faculty of Health, UFR Dentistry, Université Paris Cité, Paris, France.
Department of Odontology, AP-HP, Henri Mondor Hospital, Créteil, France.
Eur J Dent Educ. 2024 Feb;28(1):292-301. doi: 10.1111/eje.12948. Epub 2023 Aug 30.
Advances in CAD-CAM complete dentures open up opportunities in preclinical laboratory education. A cross-over study was conducted to assess the benefit of digital training in custom tray fabrication. Hypotheses were that digital training improved conceptual skill acquisition and that assessment of digital work helps in the discrimination of students' difficulty.
Third-year students were allocated either into group A and took the manual practical classes before the digital ones, or into group B (N = 154). Prior to the sessions, a motor skill test was conducted. The influence on the learning process was evaluated by comparing the groups' results to the manual lab work with a Student's t-test. The effectiveness of the assessment in discriminating manual aptitude and conceptual skill was studied through Spearman's rank coefficient between digital and manual scores in conceptual skill and with a subgroup analysis according to the results of the motor skill test. The level of significance was set up at .05. Students' satisfaction was also assessed with a questionnaire.
Students in group B achieved better scores. Spearman's rank coefficient test showed a weak correlation, R = .16. For manual lab work, the most manually skilled students did significantly better. In contrast, for the digital session, the medium manually skilled students did better. More than half of the students (55%) found the manual and digital sessions complementary, without identifying any difference depending on the learning sequence.
Digital training improved the students' results in the conventional practical exercise. Assessments of the digital and conventional custom trays were complementary in order to distinguish conceptual and motor skills.
计算机辅助设计与制造(CAD-CAM)全口义齿的进展为临床前实验室教育带来了机遇。开展了一项交叉研究,以评估数字训练在定制托盘制作中的益处。假设为数字训练可提高概念技能的习得,且对数字作品的评估有助于区分学生的困难程度。
将三年级学生分为A组,先参加手工实践课程,再参加数字实践课程,或分为B组(N = 154)。在课程开始前,进行了运动技能测试。通过用学生t检验将两组结果与手工实验室工作进行比较,评估对学习过程的影响。通过概念技能数字得分与手工得分之间的斯皮尔曼等级系数,并根据运动技能测试结果进行亚组分析,研究评估在区分手工能力和概念技能方面的有效性。显著性水平设定为0.05。还通过问卷调查评估了学生的满意度。
B组学生取得了更好的成绩。斯皮尔曼等级系数测试显示相关性较弱,R = 0.16。对于手工实验室工作,手工技能最强的学生表现明显更好。相比之下,对于数字课程,手工技能中等的学生表现更好。超过一半的学生(55%)认为手工和数字课程相辅相成,且未发现根据学习顺序有任何差异。
数字训练提高了学生在传统实践练习中的成绩。数字定制托盘和传统定制托盘的评估相辅相成,以区分概念技能和运动技能。