Dietary protein restriction induces adaptive changes in food preference, increasing protein consumption over carbohydrates or fat. We investigated whether motivation and reward signaling underpin these preferences. In an operant task, protein-restricted male mice responded more for liquid protein rewards, but not carbohydrate, fat, or sweet rewards compared to non-restricted mice. The protein restriction-induced increase in operant responding for protein was absent in -KO mice and mice with neuron-specific deletion of the FGF21 co-receptor beta-Klotho ( ) mice. Fiber photometry recording of VTA dopamine neurons revealed that oral delivery of maltodextrin triggered a larger activation as compared to casein in control-fed mice, whereas casein triggered a larger activation in protein-restricted mice. This restriction-induced shift in nutrient-specific VTA dopamine signaling was lost in -KO mice. These data strongly suggest that the increased FGF21 during protein restriction acts in the brain to induce a protein-specific appetite by specifically enhancing the reward value of protein-containing foods and the motivation to consume them.