Mellquist Madison, Hoedt Megan, Fusco Kellie N, Alef Rachel, Dittmer Kaitlyn, Ash Henry, Shoukat Wamika, Fonteyn Lorenzo, Herzstein Salome, Heineman Allie, Mayrovitz Harvey N
Osteopathic Medicine, Nova Southeastern University Dr. Kiran C. Patel College of Osteopathic Medicine, Davie, USA.
Osteopathic Medicine, Nova Southeastern University Dr. Kiran C. Patel College of Osteopathic Medicine, Clearwater, USA.
Cureus. 2024 Apr 25;16(4):e58994. doi: 10.7759/cureus.58994. eCollection 2024 Apr.
This scoping review addresses the potential maternal health outcomes of abortion restrictions in the U.S. by studying and analyzing the reported effects of abortion bans or limitations globally. The goal was to examine the medical implications for pregnant women who are unable to abort fetuses that have severe medical anomalies due to imposed restrictions. EMBASE, Medline, and CINAHL databases were searched for studies published in English concerning the medical implications of abortion restrictions in any country prior to the overturn of in 2022. For the search criteria using Boolean operators, keywords included the terms "fetal anomaly," "abortion ban," and "implications." Inclusion criteria incorporated studies published between 1980 and 2021, and controlled experimental research studies aimed to evaluate interventions were excluded. This resulted in 469 records initially found. Duplicate records were removed, and two separate tier reviews were conducted. Eleven reviewers independently screened abstracts and titles of 332 records to ascertain eligibility. Eligibility included pregnant women diagnosed with fetal anomalies, women denied access to safe abortions, and the maternal and fetal medical impacts of this. Three reviewers in the second screening independently read 36 full articles to further assess eligibility, resulting in 14 articles in the final review. Findings from this study showed that abortion bans in countries around the world have led to health complications in women seeking illegal abortion services, a decline in maternal mental health, including stress and depression, various medical complications such as obstructed labor, and an increase in high-risk fetuses born with severe deficits. The findings of this review portend similar negative consequences to be experienced by women who are subject to stricter abortion laws in the U.S.
本综述通过研究和分析全球范围内堕胎禁令或限制措施的报告影响,探讨了美国堕胎限制对孕产妇健康可能产生的后果。其目的是研究由于堕胎限制,无法终止患有严重医学异常胎儿妊娠的孕妇所面临的医学问题。研究人员检索了EMBASE、Medline和CINAHL数据库,查找2022年堕胎限制被推翻之前,以英文发表的关于任何国家堕胎限制医学影响的研究。在使用布尔运算符的检索标准中,关键词包括“胎儿异常”“堕胎禁令”和“影响”。纳入标准包括1980年至2021年发表的研究,旨在评估干预措施的对照实验研究被排除在外。这一检索最初得到469条记录。重复记录被剔除,并进行了两轮独立评审。11名评审员独立筛选了332条记录的摘要和标题,以确定其是否符合要求。符合要求的包括被诊断出胎儿异常的孕妇、被拒绝获得安全堕胎服务的妇女,以及由此产生的母婴医学影响。第二轮筛选中有3名评审员独立阅读了36篇全文,以进一步评估其是否符合要求,最终评审得到14篇文章。该研究结果表明,世界各地的堕胎禁令导致寻求非法堕胎服务的妇女出现健康并发症,孕产妇心理健康下降,包括压力和抑郁,出现各种医学并发症,如难产,以及患有严重缺陷的高危胎儿出生数量增加。本综述的研究结果预示,美国那些面临更严格堕胎法律的妇女也将经历类似的负面后果。