Centre Universitaire d'Enseignement par la Simulation (CUESim) - Hôpital Virtuel de Lorraine, Faculté de Médecine, Maïeutique et métiers de la Santé, Université de Lorraine, Nancy, France.
CHRU-Nancy, Department of Endocrinology, Diabetology and Nutrition, Université de Lorraine, Nancy, France.
Clin Teach. 2024 Dec;21(6):e13787. doi: 10.1111/tct.13787. Epub 2024 May 29.
Training of standardized patients (SPs) for national high-stakes OSCE helps to ensure a reliable assessment of student performance in various clinical scenarios. However, workflow protocols to train SPs vary. Medical schools adopt specific measures to ensure standardization.
We present a development workflow of the SPs' training framework for high-stakes OSCE using a volunteer SPs' bank. Our approach was guided by the social learning theory. Three educators and 17/20 (85%) members of our volunteer SPs' bank worked in a collaborative partnership on the construction of pedagogical content of the training framework comprising three 2-hour sessions. Since SPs have to demonstrate acquired behaviors, intended learning outcomes used the words "apply", "perform" and "participate."
A principal part of the evaluation was the achievement of intended learning outcomes by the SPs during 3 formative OSCEs. Seventeen SPs, 356 fourth year medical students and 60 examiners participated. Quantitative and qualitative data were collected by post-session questionnaires and analyzed using descriptive statistics and thematic analysis. Twelve examiners evaluated a mean of 29.7+/-0.14 SD patient-student encounters. In total, 15/16 SPs (93.8%) considered the contact with students as easy and 4 SPs (31%) reported the experience as stressful. Two themes emerged from the free-text comments: "Gaining experience as SP" and "Concerns for evaluated students."
The proposed SPs' training framework for high-stakes OSCE may be useful for other medical disciplines and health professions initiating SP-based assessment programs. The strategy of development and evaluation are outlined to guide a successful application of the curriculum standards.
培训标准化病人(SP)进行国家高风险 OSCE 有助于确保在各种临床情景下可靠评估学生的表现。然而,培训 SP 的工作流程协议有所不同。医学院采用特定措施来确保标准化。
我们使用志愿者 SP 库为高风险 OSCE 展示了 SP 培训框架的开发工作流程。我们的方法受到社会学习理论的指导。三位教育工作者和我们志愿者 SP 库的 17/20(85%)成员合作,共同构建培训框架的教学内容,包括三个 2 小时的课程。由于 SP 必须展示所获得的行为,因此预期学习成果使用了“应用”、“执行”和“参与”这几个词。
评估的一个主要部分是 SP 在 3 次形成性 OSCE 中实现预期学习成果的情况。17 名 SP、356 名四年级医学生和 60 名考官参与了评估。通过课后问卷收集定量和定性数据,并使用描述性统计和主题分析进行分析。12 名考官评估了平均 29.7±0.14 SD 的医患学生接触情况。总共有 15/16 名 SP(93.8%)认为与学生的接触很容易,而 4 名 SP(31%)表示体验有压力。从自由文本评论中出现了两个主题:“作为 SP 获得经验”和“对被评估学生的关注”。
针对高风险 OSCE 的拟议 SP 培训框架可能对其他启动基于 SP 的评估计划的医学学科和健康专业有用。开发和评估的策略概述旨在指导课程标准的成功应用。