Department of Psychology, New York University, New York, New York, United States of America.
Music and Audio Research Lab (MARL), New York University, New York, New York, United States of America.
PLoS Biol. 2024 May 30;22(5):e3002622. doi: 10.1371/journal.pbio.3002622. eCollection 2024 May.
Combinatoric linguistic operations underpin human language processes, but how meaning is composed and refined in the mind of the reader is not well understood. We address this puzzle by exploiting the ubiquitous function of negation. We track the online effects of negation ("not") and intensifiers ("really") on the representation of scalar adjectives (e.g., "good") in parametrically designed behavioral and neurophysiological (MEG) experiments. The behavioral data show that participants first interpret negated adjectives as affirmative and later modify their interpretation towards, but never exactly as, the opposite meaning. Decoding analyses of neural activity further reveal significant above chance decoding accuracy for negated adjectives within 600 ms from adjective onset, suggesting that negation does not invert the representation of adjectives (i.e., "not bad" represented as "good"); furthermore, decoding accuracy for negated adjectives is found to be significantly lower than that for affirmative adjectives. Overall, these results suggest that negation mitigates rather than inverts the neural representations of adjectives. This putative suppression mechanism of negation is supported by increased synchronization of beta-band neural activity in sensorimotor areas. The analysis of negation provides a steppingstone to understand how the human brain represents changes of meaning over time.
组合语言操作是人类语言处理的基础,但读者如何在大脑中构建和完善意义还不是很清楚。我们通过利用否定词无处不在的功能来解决这个难题。我们在参数设计的行为和神经生理学 (MEG) 实验中跟踪否定词(“不”)和强调词(“真的”)对标量形容词(如“好”)的表示的在线影响。行为数据表明,参与者首先将否定形容词解释为肯定,然后逐渐向相反的意思靠拢,但永远不会完全如此。对神经活动的解码分析进一步表明,在形容词出现后 600 毫秒内,对否定形容词进行解码的准确率明显高于随机水平,这表明否定并没有反转形容词的表示(即“不好”表示为“好”);此外,对否定形容词的解码准确率明显低于对肯定形容词的解码准确率。总的来说,这些结果表明,否定词减轻了形容词的神经表示,而不是反转了它们的表示。否定的这种假定抑制机制得到了感觉运动区域中β频带神经活动同步性增加的支持。否定分析为理解人类大脑如何随时间表示意义的变化提供了一个切入点。