Şahin Mehmet Fatih, Keleş Anil, Özcan Rıdvan, Doğan Çağrı, Topkaç Erdem Can, Akgül Murat, Yazıci Cenk Murat
Urology Department, Tekirdag Namık Kemal University, Süleymanpaşa, Tekirdağ 59020 Turkey.
Urology Department, Bursa City Hospital, Nilüfer, Bursa 16110, Turkey.
Sex Med. 2024 Jun 2;12(3):qfae036. doi: 10.1093/sexmed/qfae036. eCollection 2024 Jun.
Premature ejaculation (PE) is the most prevalent sexual dysfunction in men, and like many diseases and conditions, patients use Internet sources like ChatGPT, which is a popular artificial intelligence-based language model, for queries about this andrological disorder.
The objective of this research was to evaluate the quality, readability, and understanding of texts produced by ChatGPT in response to frequently requested inquiries on PE.
In this study we used Google Trends to identify the most frequently searched phrases related to PE. Subsequently, the discovered keywords were methodically entered into ChatGPT, and the resulting replies were assessed for quality using the Ensuring Quality Information for Patients (EQIP) program. The produced texts were assessed for readability using the Flesch-Kincaid Grade Level (FKGL), Flesch Reading Ease Score (FRES), and DISCERN metrics.
This investigation has identified substantial concerns about the quality of texts produced by ChatGPT, highlighting severe problems with reading and understanding.
The mean EQIP score for the texts was determined to be 45.93 ± 4.34, while the FRES was 15.8 ± 8.73. Additionally, the FKGL score was computed to be 15.68 ± 1.67 and the DISCERN score was 38.1 ± 3.78. The comparatively low average EQIP and DISCERN scores suggest that improvements are required to increase the quality and dependability of the presented information. In addition, the FKGL scores indicate a significant degree of linguistic intricacy, requiring a level of knowledge comparable to about 14 to 15 years of formal schooling in order to understand. The texts about treatment, which are the most frequently searched items, are more difficult to understand compared to other texts about other categories.
The results of this research suggest that compared to texts on other topics the PE texts produced by ChatGPT exhibit a higher degree of complexity, which exceeds the recommended reading threshold for effective health communication. Currently, ChatGPT is cannot be considered a substitute for comprehensive medical consultations.
This study is to our knowledge the first reported research investigating the quality and comprehensibility of information generated by ChatGPT in relation to frequently requested queries about PE. The main limitation is that the investigation included only the first 25 popular keywords in English.
ChatGPT is incapable of replacing the need for thorough medical consultations.
早泄(PE)是男性中最常见的性功能障碍,与许多疾病和病症一样,患者会使用互联网资源,如ChatGPT(一种流行的基于人工智能的语言模型)来查询这种男科疾病。
本研究的目的是评估ChatGPT针对关于早泄的常见问题所生成文本的质量、可读性和易懂性。
在本研究中,我们使用谷歌趋势来识别与早泄相关的最常搜索短语。随后,将发现的关键词系统地输入ChatGPT,并使用患者质量信息保障(EQIP)程序评估生成的回复的质量。使用弗莱什-金凯德年级水平(FKGL)、弗莱什阅读简易度得分(FRES)和辨别度指标来评估生成文本的可读性。
本次调查发现了对ChatGPT生成文本质量的重大担忧,突出了阅读和理解方面的严重问题。
文本的平均EQIP得分为45.93±4.34,而FRES为15.8±8.73。此外,计算得出的FKGL得分为15.68±1.67,辨别度得分为38.1±3.78。相对较低的平均EQIP和辨别度得分表明需要改进以提高所呈现信息的质量和可靠性。此外,FKGL得分表明语言复杂度较高,需要相当于约14至15年正规教育的知识水平才能理解。与其他类别文本相比,关于治疗(最常搜索的项目)的文本更难理解。
本研究结果表明,与其他主题的文本相比,ChatGPT生成的早泄文本表现出更高的复杂度,超过了有效健康沟通推荐的阅读阈值。目前,ChatGPT不能被视为全面医疗咨询的替代品。
据我们所知,本研究是第一项报道的关于ChatGPT针对早泄常见问题所生成信息的质量和可理解性的研究。主要局限性在于调查仅包括前25个英文热门关键词。
ChatGPT无法取代全面医疗咨询的需求。