Kass E J, Majd M
Urol Clin North Am. 1985 Feb;12(1):133-41.
Our clinical experience over the past 5 years would suggest that both the diuretic renogram and the Whitaker study permit an objective and quantitative assessment of urinary obstruction. The diagnostic accuracy of both studies exceeds 90 per cent, although neither study has proved to be infallible. Both have potential sources of error that must be monitored carefully if their reliability is to be maximized. Potential sources of error in the diuretic renogram include the state of hydration, renal functional status, distensibility and volume of the collecting system, a filled bladder, and ability to respond to the diuretic. Its reliability can be increased if the standard testing protocol is followed, the study closely monitored, and the limitations of the test realized. Interpretation of the diuretic renogram based only upon the appearance of the washout curve without consideration of the calculated half time or the sequential analogue images is unreliable and in our experience would have been responsible for an incorrect interpretation in 40 per cent of patients. The diuretic renal scan is used as the initial testing modality because it is reliable, reproducible, noninvasive, and objective and provides important information concerning individual renal function. Over 80 per cent of children with hydronephrosis can be completely evaluated by the diuretic renogram alone without the need for more invasive testing modalities. Nevertheless, the pressure perfusion study will continue to be necessary for the evaluation of certain individuals. Because of its invasive nature, we prefer to reserve this study for very specific, well-defined circumstances.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
我们过去5年的临床经验表明,利尿肾图和惠特克试验均能对尿路梗阻进行客观、定量的评估。两项检查的诊断准确率均超过90%,尽管尚无一项检查被证明是万无一失的。两者都有潜在的误差来源,若要使其可靠性最大化,必须仔细监测。利尿肾图的潜在误差来源包括水化状态、肾功能状态、集合系统的可扩张性和容量、充盈的膀胱以及对利尿剂的反应能力。如果遵循标准测试方案、密切监测检查过程并了解该检查的局限性,其可靠性可以提高。仅根据洗脱曲线的形态而不考虑计算出的半衰期或连续的模拟图像来解释利尿肾图是不可靠的,根据我们的经验,这会导致40%的患者出现错误解读。利尿肾扫描被用作初始检测方式,因为它可靠、可重复、无创、客观,并且能提供有关个体肾功能的重要信息。超过80%的肾积水患儿仅通过利尿肾图就能得到全面评估,无需更具侵入性的检测方式。然而,对于某些个体的评估,压力灌注研究仍是必要的。由于其侵入性,我们倾向于仅在非常特殊、明确界定的情况下进行这项检查。(摘要截选至250词)