The University of Melbourne, School of Health Sciences, Carlton, Victoria, Australia.
The Victorian Aboriginal Child and Community Agency, Practice and Evidence Development and Outcomes and Practice, Preston, Victoria, Australia.
Am J Community Psychol. 2024 Sep;74(1-2):5-15. doi: 10.1002/ajcp.12759. Epub 2024 Jun 4.
Aboriginal Australians experience disproportionately high rates of mental health problems as the result of European colonisation, and Western evidence-based treatment has been strikingly ineffective in improving the situation. Cultural Therapeutic Ways is a culturally specific healing and wellbeing practice framework developed by the Victorian Aboriginal Child and Community Agency that focuses on culturally based practices, trauma awareness, and self-determination. Despite wide recognition of the importance of these elements in Indigenous healing and wellbeing programs, its measurable empirical impact is currently unclear. This paper summarises findings from a systematic scoping review to ascertain the published knowledge base for Cultural Therapeutic Ways and the gaps in knowledge that can inform future evaluation. Forty-two studies of programs that applied Cultural Therapeutic Ways with Indigenous participants from Australia, Canada, New Zealand, and the United States of America were identified from the literature search. Services based on Cultural Therapeutic Ways contributed to healing and wellbeing because they create safety, strengthen cultural connections, develop empowerment and provide opportunities to release emotion, and increase social and spiritual support. As the review set out to determine the published evidence base for Cultural Therapeutic Ways, other effective approaches may have been overlooked. To develop the evidence base for Cultural Therapeutic Ways, service design must clearly describe target groups, whether the program is delivered by Aboriginal people, the processes of Cultural Therapeutic Ways utilised in service delivery, and how they are blended with Western approaches. Research efforts could also productively be focused on identifying or constructing culturally appropriate outcome measures.
澳大利亚原住民因欧洲殖民而经历了不成比例的高心理健康问题率,而西方基于证据的治疗方法在改善这种情况方面效果显著不佳。文化治疗方法是维多利亚原住民儿童和社区机构开发的一种具有文化特异性的治疗和健康实践框架,专注于基于文化的实践、创伤意识和自我决定。尽管人们广泛认识到这些元素在原住民治疗和健康计划中的重要性,但它们对衡量的影响目前尚不清楚。本文总结了系统范围审查的结果,以确定文化治疗方法的已发表知识库以及可以为未来评估提供信息的知识空白。从文献检索中确定了来自澳大利亚、加拿大、新西兰和美国的原住民参与者应用文化治疗方法的 42 项计划研究。基于文化治疗方法的服务之所以有助于治疗和健康,是因为它们创造了安全环境,加强了文化联系,培养了赋权意识并提供了释放情绪的机会,并增加了社会和精神支持。由于该审查旨在确定文化治疗方法的已发表证据基础,因此可能忽略了其他有效方法。为了发展文化治疗方法的证据基础,服务设计必须清楚地描述目标群体,该计划是否由原住民提供,在服务提供中使用的文化治疗方法的过程,以及它们如何与西方方法相结合。研究工作也可以集中精力确定或构建文化上适当的结果衡量标准。