Hibbard Patrick Franklin
Oregon Social Learning Center, Eugene, USA.
Crime Delinq. 2024 Jun;70(6-7):1567-1591. doi: 10.1177/00111287221131496. Epub 2022 Dec 14.
Though the literature largely recognizes adult drug treatment courts (ADCs) as beneficial to participants, with lower rates of recidivism and drug use, the question remains of how ADCs impact communities and how other institutions (e.g., law enforcement) react to their presence. This study extends previous work estimating higher arrests associated with ADCs, particularly for crimes involving higher degrees of law enforcement discretion. Results indicate lower drug possession arrest rates for White residents in rural communities, and higher in urban areas, generally, but especially for Black citizens. Though the exact source of these changes has yet to be determined, current analysis indicates larger effect sizes for arrests scaled per officer, as compared to per population, pointing toward changes in law enforcement behavior.
尽管文献大多认为成人毒品治疗法庭(ADCs)对参与者有益,其累犯率和吸毒率较低,但问题仍然存在:ADCs如何影响社区,以及其他机构(如执法部门)对其存在会作何反应。本研究扩展了先前的工作,估计与ADCs相关的逮捕率更高,特别是对于涉及更高程度执法自由裁量权的犯罪。结果表明,农村社区白人居民的持有毒品逮捕率较低,而城市地区的逮捕率普遍较高,尤其是对黑人公民而言。尽管这些变化的确切来源尚未确定,但目前的分析表明,与按人口计算相比,按每名警官计算的逮捕效应量更大,这表明执法行为发生了变化。