Department of Water Resources Development & Management, Indian Institute of Technology Roorkee, Roorkee, India.
Space Applications Centre, Indian Space Research Organization, Ahmedabad, Gujarat, India.
Environ Monit Assess. 2024 Jun 11;196(7):608. doi: 10.1007/s10661-024-12746-4.
Satellite-based precipitation estimates are a critical source of information for understanding and predicting hydrological processes at regional or global scales. Given the potential variability in the accuracy and reliability of these estimates, comprehensive performance assessments are essential before their application in specific hydrological contexts. In this study, six satellite-based precipitation products (SPPs), namely, CHIRPS, CMORPH, GSMaP, IMERG, MSWEP, and PERSIANN, were evaluated for their utility in hydrological modeling, specifically in simulating streamflow using the Variable Infiltration Capacity (VIC) model. The performance of the VIC model under varying flow conditions and timescales was assessed using statistical indicators, viz., R, KGE, PBias, RMSE, and RSR. The findings of the study demonstrate the effectiveness of VIC model in simulating hydrological components and its applicability in evaluating the accuracy and reliability of SPPs. The SPPs were shown to be valuable for streamflow simulation at monthly and daily timescales, as confirmed by various performance measures. Moreover, the performance of SPPs for simulating extreme flow events (streamflow above 75%, 90%, and 95%) using the VIC model was assessed and a significant decrease in the performance was observed for high-flow events. Comparative analysis revealed the superiority of IMERG and CMORPH for streamflow simulation at daily timescale and high-flow conditions. In contrast, the performances of CHIRPS and PERSIANN were found to be poor. This study highlights the importance of thoroughly assessing the SPPs in modeling diverse flow conditions.
卫星降水估计是理解和预测区域或全球尺度水文过程的重要信息来源。鉴于这些估计的准确性和可靠性存在潜在的变化,在将其应用于特定的水文背景之前,进行全面的性能评估至关重要。在这项研究中,评估了六种基于卫星的降水产品(SPP),即 CHIRPS、CMORPH、GSMaP、IMERG、MSWEP 和 PERSIANN,以评估它们在水文建模中的效用,特别是在使用可变入渗能力(VIC)模型模拟径流下的效用。使用统计指标(即 R、KGE、PBias、RMSE 和 RSR)评估 VIC 模型在不同流量条件和时间尺度下的性能。研究结果表明,VIC 模型在模拟水文组成部分方面是有效的,并且可以用于评估 SPP 的准确性和可靠性。结果表明,SPP 可用于模拟月和日时间尺度的径流量,这得到了各种性能指标的证实。此外,还评估了 VIC 模型模拟极端流量事件(流量超过 75%、90%和 95%)的 SPP 性能,并且观察到高流量事件的性能显著下降。比较分析表明,IMERG 和 CMORPH 在日时间尺度和高流量条件下具有模拟径流量的优势。相比之下,CHIRPS 和 PERSIANN 的性能较差。这项研究强调了在模型化不同流量条件下彻底评估 SPP 的重要性。