Kurtoğlu Ayşe, Yıldız Abdullah, Arda Berna
Department of Medical History and Ethics, Ankara University School of Medicine, Ankara, Türkiye.
Front Bioeng Biotechnol. 2024 May 28;12:1397796. doi: 10.3389/fbioe.2024.1397796. eCollection 2024.
Synthetic biology is designing and creating biological tools and systems for useful purposes. It uses knowledge from biology, such as biotechnology, molecular biology, biophysics, biochemistry, bioinformatics, and other disciplines, such as engineering, mathematics, computer science, and electrical engineering. It is recognized as both a branch of science and technology. The scope of synthetic biology ranges from modifying existing organisms to gain new properties to creating a living organism from non-living components. Synthetic biology has many applications in important fields such as energy, chemistry, medicine, environment, agriculture, national security, and nanotechnology. The development of synthetic biology also raises ethical and social debates. This article aims to identify the place of ethics in synthetic biology. In this context, the theoretical ethical debates on synthetic biology from the 2000s to 2020, when the development of synthetic biology was relatively faster, were analyzed using the systematic review method. Based on the results of the analysis, the main ethical problems related to the field, problems that are likely to arise, and suggestions for solutions to these problems are included. The data collection phase of the study included a literature review conducted according to protocols, including planning, screening, selection and evaluation. The analysis and synthesis process was carried out in the next stage, and the main themes related to synthetic biology and ethics were identified. Searches were conducted in Web of Science, Scopus, PhilPapers and MEDLINE databases. Theoretical research articles and reviews published in peer-reviewed journals until the end of 2020 were included in the study. The language of publications was English. According to preliminary data, 1,453 publications were retrieved from the four databases. Considering the inclusion and exclusion criteria, 58 publications were analyzed in the study. Ethical debates on synthetic biology have been conducted on various issues. In this context, the ethical debates in this article were examined under five themes: the moral status of synthetic biology products, synthetic biology and the meaning of life, synthetic biology and metaphors, synthetic biology and knowledge, and expectations, concerns, and problem solving: risk caution.
合成生物学是为了有用的目的而设计和创建生物工具及系统。它运用来自生物学的知识,如生物技术、分子生物学、生物物理学、生物化学、生物信息学等,以及其他学科的知识,如工程学、数学、计算机科学和电气工程学。它被公认为是一门科学技术分支。合成生物学的范围涵盖从改造现有生物体以获得新特性到利用非生物成分创造活生物体。合成生物学在能源、化学、医学、环境、农业、国家安全和纳米技术等重要领域有许多应用。合成生物学的发展也引发了伦理和社会辩论。本文旨在确定伦理在合成生物学中的地位。在此背景下,运用系统综述方法分析了21世纪至2020年(合成生物学发展相对较快的时期)关于合成生物学的理论伦理辩论。基于分析结果,纳入了与该领域相关的主要伦理问题、可能出现的问题以及针对这些问题的解决建议。该研究的数据收集阶段包括按照方案进行的文献综述,包括规划、筛选、选择和评估。分析与综合过程在接下来的阶段进行,确定了与合成生物学和伦理相关的主要主题。在科学网、Scopus、PhilPapers和MEDLINE数据库中进行了检索。研究纳入了截至2020年底在同行评审期刊上发表的理论研究文章和综述。出版物语言为英语。根据初步数据,从这四个数据库中检索到1453篇出版物。考虑纳入和排除标准,该研究分析了58篇出版物。关于合成生物学的伦理辩论涉及多个问题。在此背景下,本文的伦理辩论在五个主题下进行了审视:合成生物学产品的道德地位、合成生物学与生命的意义、合成生物学与隐喻、合成生物学与知识,以及期望、关注和问题解决:风险与谨慎。