Zhao Bo, Song Yuan-Meng, Lu Meng-Qi, Bai Yin-Hu, Chen Hao-da, Gao Sai, Wang Lin-Jing, Zhang Lu-Lu, Cui Jian-Sheng
College of Environmental Science and Engineering, Hebei University of Science and Technology, Shijiazhuang 050000, China.
Hebei Water Conservancy Planning and Design Institute Limited Company, Shijiazhuang 050021, China.
Huan Jing Ke Xue. 2024 Jun 8;45(6):3176-3185. doi: 10.13227/j.hjkx.202306088.
Rivers are important reservoirs of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs). However, most current studies have focused on the temporal and spatial distribution, and data on the differences in the species and abundance of ARGs between urban and rural rivers is still lacking for certain areas. In view of this, two rural rivers and three urban rivers were selected in Shijiazhuang City. In both December 2020 and April 2021, sediments were collected at 15 sampling sites. Metagenomic sequencing technology was used to compare the differences in temporal-spatial variation for ARGs in sediments. The results showed that:① 162 and 79 ARGs were detected in urban (4 776 ±4 452) and rural rivers (1 043 ±632), respectively. The abundance and species of ARGs in urban rivers were higher than those in rural rivers. ② The relative abundances of sulfonamide (SAs,27 %), aminoglycoside (AGs,26 %), and multidrug (MDs,15 %) ARGs had the highest abundance in urban rivers, whereas the relative abundance of MDs ARGs was highest in rural rivers (65 %). On the whole, the complexity of ARGs in urban rivers was higher than that in rural rivers. ③ There was a significant positive correlation between SAs, AGs, MDs, tetracycline, phenicol, macrolides-lincosamids-streptogramins (MLS), -lactams, and diaminopyrimidine ARGs in urban rivers ( < 0.01); however, there was a significant negative correlation between glycopeptide ARGs and all types of ARGs ( < 0.05 and < 0.01). There was a significant positive correlation between MDs and SAs ARGs in rural rivers ( < 0.05), but there was a significant negative correlation between amino aminocoumarin, peptide, rifamycin, and fosfomycin ARGs ( < 0.05 and < 0.01). ④ For the temporal variation in urban rivers, 162 ARGs (4 776 ±4 452) and 148 ARGs (5 673 ±5 626) were detected in December and April, respectively. For the temporal variation in rural rivers, 79 species (1 043 ±632) and 46 species (467 ±183) were detected in December and April, respectively. ⑤ RDA analysis results showed that the spatial-temporal distributions of ARGs in urban and rural rivers were different. Correlation analysis showed that the ARGs in urban rivers were significantly correlated with the number of industrial enterprises, whereas the ARGs in rural rivers were significantly correlated with the output value of animal husbandry. In general, this study identified the main influencing factors for ARGs in different rivers and provided data support for ARGs risk management in different rivers.
河流是抗生素抗性基因(ARGs)的重要储存库。然而,目前大多数研究集中在时空分布上,某些地区城乡河流之间ARGs的种类和丰度差异数据仍然缺乏。鉴于此,在石家庄市选取了两条农村河流和三条城市河流。在2020年12月和2021年4月,分别在15个采样点采集沉积物。采用宏基因组测序技术比较沉积物中ARGs的时空变化差异。结果表明:①在城市河流(4776±4452)和农村河流(1043±632)中分别检测到162种和79种ARGs。城市河流中ARGs的丰度和种类高于农村河流。②磺胺类(SAs,27%)、氨基糖苷类(AGs,26%)和多药类(MDs,15%)ARGs在城市河流中的相对丰度最高,而MDs ARGs在农村河流中的相对丰度最高(65%)。总体而言,城市河流中ARGs的复杂性高于农村河流。③城市河流中SAs、AGs、MDs、四环素、氯霉素、大环内酯-林可酰胺-链阳霉素(MLS)、β-内酰胺和二氨基嘧啶ARGs之间存在显著正相关(<0.01);然而,糖肽类ARGs与所有类型的ARGs之间存在显著负相关(<0.05和<0.01)。农村河流中MDs和SAs ARGs之间存在显著正相关(<0.05),但氨基香豆素、肽类、利福霉素和磷霉素ARGs之间存在显著负相关(<0.05和<0.01)。④对于城市河流的时间变化,12月和4月分别检测到162种ARGs(4776±4452)和148种ARGs(5673±5626)。对于农村河流的时间变化,12月和4月分别检测到79种(1043±632)和46种(467±183)。⑤冗余分析(RDA)结果表明,城乡河流中ARGs的时空分布不同。相关性分析表明,城市河流中的ARGs与工业企业数量显著相关,而农村河流中的ARGs与畜牧业产值显著相关。总体而言,本研究确定了不同河流中ARGs的主要影响因素,为不同河流的ARGs风险管理提供了数据支持。