Department of Medical and Surgical Sciences, University of Bologna, Bologna, Italy.
IRCCS Azienda Ospedaliero-Universitaria di Bologna, European Reference Network on Hepatological Diseases (ERN RARE-LIVER), Bologna, Italy.
Clin Exp Immunol. 2024 Aug 9;217(3):233-239. doi: 10.1093/cei/uxae051.
Smooth muscle antibodies (SMA) with anti-microfilament actin (MF-SMA) specificity are regarded as highly specific markers of type 1 autoimmune hepatitis (AIH-1) but their recognition relying on immunofluorescence of vessel, glomeruli, and tubules (SMA-VGT pattern) in rodent kidney tissue, is restricted by operator-dependent interpretation. A gold standard method for their identification is not available. We assessed and compared the diagnostic accuracy for AIH-1 of an embryonal aorta vascular smooth muscle (VSM) cell line-based assay with those of the rodent tissue-based assay for the detection of MF-SMA pattern in AIH-1 patients and controls. Sera from 138 AIH-1 patients and 295 controls (105 primary biliary cholangitis, 40 primary sclerosing cholangitis, 50 chronic viral hepatitis, 20 alcohol-related liver disease, 40 steatotic liver disease, and 40 healthy controls) were assayed for MF-SMA and SMA-VGT using VSM-based and rodent tissue-based assays, respectively. MF-SMA and SMA-VGT were found in 96 (70%) and 87 (63%) AIH-1 patients, and 2 controls (P < 0.0001). Compared with SMA-VGT, MF-SMA showed similar specificity (99%), higher sensitivity (70% vs 63%, P = ns) and likelihood ratio for a positive test (70 vs 65). Nine (7%) AIH-1 patients were MF-SMA positive despite being SMA-VGT negative. Overall agreement between SMA-VGT and MF-SMA was 87% (kappa coefficient 0.870, [0.789-0.952]). MF-SMA were associated with higher serum γ-globulin [26 (12-55) vs 20 g/l (13-34), P < 0.005] and immunoglobulin G (IgG) levels [3155 (1296-7344) vs 2050 mg/dl (1377-3357), P < 0.002]. The easily recognizable IFL MF-SMA pattern on VSM cells strongly correlated with SMA-VGT and has an equally high specificity for AIH-1. Confirmation of these results in other laboratories would support the clinical application of the VSM cell-based assay for reliable detection of AIH-specific SMA.
平滑肌抗体(SMA)具有抗微丝肌动蛋白(MF-SMA)特异性,被认为是 1 型自身免疫性肝炎(AIH-1)的高度特异性标志物,但它们的识别依赖于啮齿动物肾组织中血管、肾小球和小管的免疫荧光(SMA-VGT 模式),这受到操作人员解释的限制。目前还没有一种用于鉴定它们的金标准方法。我们评估并比较了基于胚胎主动脉血管平滑肌(VSM)细胞系的检测方法与基于啮齿动物组织的检测方法对 AIH-1 患者和对照组中 MF-SMA 模式的诊断准确性。使用基于 VSM 的和基于啮齿动物组织的检测方法分别检测了来自 138 名 AIH-1 患者和 295 名对照组(105 名原发性胆汁性胆管炎、40 名原发性硬化性胆管炎、50 名慢性病毒性肝炎、20 名酒精性肝病、40 名脂肪性肝病和 40 名健康对照)的血清中的 MF-SMA 和 SMA-VGT。在 96 名(70%)AIH-1 患者和 2 名对照者中发现了 MF-SMA 和 SMA-VGT(P<0.0001)。与 SMA-VGT 相比,MF-SMA 具有相似的特异性(99%)、更高的敏感性(70%对 63%,P=ns)和阳性试验的可能性比(70 对 65)。9 名(7%)AIH-1 患者尽管 SMA-VGT 阴性但 MF-SMA 阳性。SMA-VGT 和 MF-SMA 之间的总体一致性为 87%(kappa 系数 0.870,[0.789-0.952])。MF-SMA 与较高的血清γ球蛋白[26(12-55)比 20 g/l(13-34),P<0.005]和免疫球蛋白 G(IgG)水平[3155(1296-7344)比 2050 mg/dl(1377-3357),P<0.002]相关。在 VSM 细胞上容易识别的 IFL MF-SMA 模式与 SMA-VGT 强烈相关,并且对 AIH-1 具有相同的高特异性。在其他实验室中确认这些结果将支持基于 VSM 细胞的检测方法在可靠检测 AIH 特异性 SMA 方面的临床应用。