Ogunyemi Dotun, Thind Birpartap S, Teixeira Amir, Sams Clarence M, Ojo Matthias, Dinkins Grace Anne E, Serseni Dragos
DIO, Associate Dean of Graduate Medical Education; Charles R Drew University, College of Medicine, Los Angeles, CA, USA.
Medical Student, California University of Science and Medicine, Colton, CA, USA.
Adv Med Educ Pract. 2024 Jun 18;15:575-583. doi: 10.2147/AMEP.S460970. eCollection 2024.
Cultural humility is a lifelong commitment to self-evaluation, redressing power imbalances in patient-physician relationships and developing mutually trusting beneficial partnerships.
The objective of this study was to determine the feasibility and efficacy of cultural humility training.
From July 2020-March 2021, 90-minute educational workshops attended by 133 medical students, resident physicians and medical education faculty included 1) pre- and post- intervention surveys; 2) interactive presentation on equity and cultural humility principles; 3) participants explored sociocultural identities and power; and 4) reflective group discussions.
There were significant increases from pre to post intervention assessments for perception scores (3.89 [SEM= 0.04] versus 4.22 [0.08], p<0.001) and knowledge scores (0.52 [0.02] versus 0.67 [0.02], p<0.001). Commonest identities participants recognized as changing over time were personality = 40%, appearance = 36%, and age =35%. Commonest identities experienced as oppressed/subjugated were race/ethnicity = 54%, gender = 40% and religion = 28%; whilst commonest identities experienced as privileged were gender= 49%, race/ethnicity = 42% and appearance= 25%. Male participants assigned mean power score of 73% to gender identity compared to mean power score of -8% by female participants (P<0.001). Non-Hispanic Whites had mean power score for race identity of 62% compared to 13% for non-white participants (p<0.001). English as a second language was only acknowledged as an oppressed/subjugated identity by those born outside the United States (p<0.001).
An interactive educational workshop can increase participants' knowledge and perceptions regarding cultural humility. Participants can self-reflect to recognize sociocultural identities that are oppressed/subjugated or privileged.
文化谦逊是一种对自我评估的终身承诺,旨在纠正医患关系中的权力不平衡,并建立相互信任的有益伙伴关系。
本研究的目的是确定文化谦逊培训的可行性和有效性。
2020年7月至2021年3月,133名医学生、住院医师和医学教育教员参加了90分钟的教育工作坊,包括:1)干预前后的调查;2)关于公平和文化谦逊原则的互动式讲座;3)参与者探索社会文化身份和权力;4)反思性小组讨论。
干预前后评估的认知得分(3.89[标准误=0.04]对4.22[0.08],p<0.001)和知识得分(0.52[0.02]对0.67[0.02],p<0.001)有显著提高。参与者认为随时间变化最常见的身份是性格=40%,外貌=36%,年龄=35%。被认为受到压迫/压制的最常见身份是种族/族裔=54%,性别=40%,宗教=28%;而被认为享有特权的最常见身份是性别=49%,种族/族裔=42%,外貌=25%。男性参与者将性别身份的平均权力得分定为73%,而女性参与者的平均权力得分是-8%(P<0.001)。非西班牙裔白人的种族身份平均权力得分为62%,而非白人参与者为13%(p<0.001)。只有在美国境外出生的人将英语作为第二语言视为受压迫/压制的身份(p<0.001)。
互动式教育工作坊可以增加参与者关于文化谦逊的知识和认知。参与者可以通过自我反思来认识到那些受到压迫/压制或享有特权的社会文化身份。