Department of Earth & Environmental Sciences, Hazara University, Mansehra, 21120, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa, Pakistan.
Key Laboratory of Mechanics On Disaster and Environment in Western China, the Ministry of Education of China, Lanzhou University, Lanzhou, 730000, China.
Environ Sci Pollut Res Int. 2024 Jul;31(31):43967-43986. doi: 10.1007/s11356-024-34046-7. Epub 2024 Jun 25.
Renowned for its agriculture, livestock, and mining, Zhob district, Pakistan, faces the urgent problem of declining groundwater quality due to natural and human-induced factors. This deterioration poses significant challenges for residents who rely on groundwater for drinking, domestic, and irrigation purposes. Therefore, this novel study aimed to carry out a comprehensive assessment of groundwater quality in Zhob district, considering various aspects such as hydrochemical characteristics, human health risks, and suitability for drinking and irrigation purposes. While previous studies may have focused on one or a few of these aspects, this study integrates multiple analyses to provide a holistic understanding of the groundwater quality situation in the region. Additionally, the study applies a range of common hydrochemical analysis methods (acid-base titration, flame atomic absorption spectrometry, and ion chromatography), drinking water quality index (WQI), irrigation indices, and health risk assessment models, using 19 water quality parameters. This multi-method approach enhances the robustness and accuracy of the assessment, providing valuable insights for decision-makers and stakeholders. The results revealed that means of the majority of water quality parameters, such as pH (7.64), electrical conductivity (830.13 μScm), total dissolved solids (562.83 mgL), as well as various anions, and cations, were in line with drinking water norms. However, the water quality index (WQI) predominantly indicated poor drinking water quality (range = 51-75) at 50% sites, followed by good quality (range = 26-50) at 37% of the sites, with 10% of the sites exhibiting very poor quality (range = 76-100). For irrigation purposes, indices such as sodium percent (mean = 31.37%), sodium adsorption ratio (mean = 0.98 meqL), residual sodium carbonate (- 3.15 meqL), Kelley's index (mean = 0.49), and permeability (mean = 49.11%) indicated suitability without immediate treatment. However, the magnesium hazard (mean = 46.11%) and potential salinity (mean = 3.93) demonstrated that prolonged application of groundwater for irrigation needs soil management to avoid soil compaction and salinity. Water samples exhibit characteristics of medium salinity and low alkalinity (C2S1) as well as high salinity and low alkalinity (C3S1) categories. The Gibbs diagram results revealed that rock weathering, including silicate weathering and cation exchange, is the primary factor governing the hydrochemistry of groundwater. The hydrochemical composition is dominated by mixed Ca-Mg-Cl, followed by Na-Cl and Mg-Cl types. Furthermore, the human health risk assessment highlighted that fluoride (F) posed a higher risk compared with nitrate (NO). Additionally, ingestion was found to pose a higher risk to health compared to dermal contact, with children being particularly vulnerable. The average hazard index (HI) for children was 1.24, surpassing the allowable limit of 1, indicating detrimental health effects on this subpopulation. Conversely, average HI values for adult females (0.59) and adult males (0.44) were within safe levels, suggesting minimal concerns for these demographic groups. Overall, the study's interdisciplinary approach and depth of analysis make a significant contribution to understanding groundwater quality dynamics and associated risks in Zhob district, potentially informing future management and mitigation strategies.
以农业、畜牧业和采矿业而闻名的巴基斯坦佐布地区由于自然和人为因素,面临着地下水质量下降的紧迫问题。这种恶化对依赖地下水饮用、家庭和灌溉用途的居民构成了重大挑战。因此,本研究旨在对佐布地区的地下水质量进行全面评估,考虑了水化学成分特征、人类健康风险以及饮用和灌溉用途的适宜性等各个方面。虽然之前的研究可能集中在这些方面的一个或几个方面,但本研究综合了多种分析方法,从整体上了解该地区的地下水质量状况。此外,本研究应用了一系列常见的水化学成分分析方法(酸碱滴定、火焰原子吸收光谱法和离子色谱法)、饮用水质量指数(WQI)、灌溉指数和健康风险评估模型,共使用了 19 个水质参数。这种多方法的方法提高了评估的稳健性和准确性,为决策者和利益相关者提供了有价值的见解。结果表明,大多数水质参数的平均值,如 pH 值(7.64)、电导率(830.13 μScm)、总溶解固体(562.83 mgL)以及各种阴离子和阳离子,均符合饮用水标准。然而,水质量指数(WQI)主要表明 50%的地点的饮用水质量较差(范围=51-75),其次是 37%的地点的水质良好(范围=26-50),10%的地点的水质极差(范围=76-100)。就灌溉用途而言,钠离子百分比(均值=31.37%)、钠离子吸附比(均值=0.98 meqL)、剩余碳酸钠(-3.15 meqL)、凯利指数(均值=0.49)和渗透率(均值=49.11%)等指数表明在无需立即处理的情况下可直接用于灌溉。然而,镁的危害(均值=46.11%)和潜在盐度(均值=3.93)表明,地下水的长期灌溉应用需要土壤管理来避免土壤板结和盐度增加。水样具有中盐度和低碱度(C2S1)以及高盐度和低碱度(C3S1)的特征。Gibbs 图的结果表明,岩石风化,包括硅酸盐风化和阳离子交换,是控制地下水水化学成分的主要因素。水化学成分主要由混合的 Ca-Mg-Cl 组成,其次是 Na-Cl 和 Mg-Cl 类型。此外,人类健康风险评估强调,与硝酸盐(NO)相比,氟(F)构成更高的风险。此外,与皮肤接触相比,摄入被认为对健康构成更高的风险,儿童尤其容易受到影响。儿童的平均危害指数(HI)为 1.24,超过了 1 的允许限值,表明这一亚群存在有害的健康影响。相反,成年女性(0.59)和成年男性(0.44)的平均 HI 值处于安全水平,表明这些人群的健康风险较低。总体而言,该研究的跨学科方法和深度分析为了解佐布地区地下水质量动态和相关风险做出了重要贡献,可能为未来的管理和缓解策略提供信息。