Boccia Gennaro, Brustio Paolo Riccardo, Beratto Luca, Peluso Ilaria, Ferrara Roberto, Munzi Diego, Toti Elisabetta, Raguzzini Anna, Sciarra Tommaso, Rainoldi Alberto
Department of Clinical and Biological Sciences, University of Turin, 10043 Turin, Italy.
Neuromuscular Function Research Group, School of Exercise and Sport Science, University of Turin, 10126 Turin, Italy.
J Funct Morphol Kinesiol. 2024 Jun 20;9(2):108. doi: 10.3390/jfmk9020108.
This study aimed to compare neuromuscular fatigability of the elbow flexors and extensors between athletes with amputation (AMP) and athletes with spinal cord injury (SCI) for maximum voluntary force (MVF) and rate of force development (RFD). We recruited 20 para-athletes among those participating at two training camps (2022) for Italian Paralympic veterans. Ten athletes with SCI (two with tetraplegia and eight with paraplegia) were compared to 10 athletes with amputation (above the knee, N = 3; below the knee, N = 6; forearm, N = 1). We quantified MVF, RFD at 50, 100, and 150 ms, and maximal RFD (RFDpeak) of elbow flexors and extensors before and after an incremental arm cranking to voluntary fatigue. We also measured the RFD scaling factor (RFD-SF), which is the linear relationship between peak force and peak RFD quantified in a series of ballistic contractions of submaximal amplitude. SCI showed lower levels of MVF and RFD in both muscle groups (all values ≤ 0.045). Despite this, the decrease in MVF (Cohen's d = 0.425, < 0.001) and RFDpeak (d = 0.424, = 0.003) after the incremental test did not show any difference between pathological conditions. Overall, RFD at 50 ms showed the greatest decrease (d = 0.741, < 0.001), RFD at 100 ms showed a small decrease (d = 0.382, = 0.020), and RFD at 150 ms did not decrease ( = 0.272). The RFD-SF decreased more in SCI than AMP ( < 0.0001). Muscle fatigability impacted not only maximal force expressions but also the quickness of ballistic contractions of submaximal amplitude, particularly in SCI. This may affect various sports and daily living activities of wheelchair users. Early RFD (i.e., ≤50 ms) was notably affected by muscle fatigability.
本研究旨在比较截肢运动员(AMP)和脊髓损伤运动员(SCI)肘屈肌和伸肌在最大自主力量(MVF)和力量发展速率(RFD)方面的神经肌肉疲劳性。我们从参加2022年意大利残奥会老将的两个训练营的运动员中招募了20名残奥运动员。将10名脊髓损伤运动员(2名四肢瘫痪,8名截瘫)与10名截肢运动员(膝上截肢,N = 3;膝下截肢,N = 6;前臂截肢,N = 1)进行比较。我们在递增式手臂曲柄运动至自愿疲劳前后,对肘屈肌和伸肌的MVF、50、100和150毫秒时的RFD以及最大RFD(RFDpeak)进行了量化。我们还测量了RFD缩放因子(RFD-SF),它是在一系列次最大幅度的弹道收缩中量化的峰值力量与峰值RFD之间的线性关系。SCI在两个肌肉群中的MVF和RFD水平较低(所有p值≤0.045)。尽管如此,递增测试后MVF(科恩d = 0.425,p < 0.001)和RFDpeak(d = 0.424,p = 0.003)的下降在不同病理状况之间未显示出任何差异。总体而言,50毫秒时的RFD下降最大(d = 0.741,p < 0.001),100毫秒时的RFD有小幅下降(d = 0.382,p = 0.020),150毫秒时的RFD没有下降(p = 0.272)。RFD-SF在SCI中比AMP下降得更多(p < 0.0001)。肌肉疲劳性不仅影响最大力量表现,还影响次最大幅度弹道收缩的速度,尤其是在SCI中。这可能会影响轮椅使用者的各种运动和日常生活活动。早期RFD(即≤50毫秒)受肌肉疲劳性的影响尤为明显。