Tan Mei-Ling, Shen Yan-Jun, Chen Qi-Liang, Wu Feng-Rui, Liu Zhi-Hao
Chongqing Key Laboratory of Conservation and Utilization of Freshwater Fishes, College of Life Sciences, Chongqing Normal University, Chongqing, 401331, China; Laboratory of Water Ecological Health and Environmental Safety, College of Life Sciences, Chongqing Normal University, Chongqing, 401331, China.
Anhui Province Key Laboratory of Environmental Hormone and Reproduction, Fuyang Normal University, Fuyang, 236037, China.
Aquat Toxicol. 2024 Aug;273:107008. doi: 10.1016/j.aquatox.2024.107008. Epub 2024 Jun 21.
Environmental estrogens (EEs) are found extensively in natural waters and negatively affect fish reproduction. Research on the reproductive toxicity of EEs mixtures in fish at environmentally relevant concentrations is scarce. In this study, adult male zebrafish were exposed for 60 days to EES (a mixture of EEs), EE2-low (5.55 ng/L, with an estrogenic potency equal to EES), and EE2-high (11.1 ng/L). After exposure, the expression levels of vtg1, vtg3, and esr1 in the livers in EES-treated fish remained unaltered, whereas they were significantly increased in EE2-treated fish. Both EE2-high and EES exposures notably reduced the gonad somatic index and sperm count. A disrupted spermatogenesis was also observed in the testes of EE2-high- and EES-exposed fish, along with an alteration in the expression of genes associated with spermatogonial proliferation (pcna, nanog), cell cycle transition (cyclinb1, cyclind1), and meiosis (aldh1a2, cyp26a1, sycp3). Both EE2 and EES significantly lowered plasma 11-ketotestosterone levels in males, likely by inhibiting the expression level of genes for its synthesis (scc, cyp17a1 and cyp11b2), and increased 17β-estradiol (E2) levels, possibly through upregulating the expression of cyp19a1a. A significant increase in tnfrsf1a expression and the tnfrsf1a/tnfrsf1b ratio in EE2-high and EES-treated males also suggests increased apoptosis via the extrinsic pathway. Further investigation showed that both EE2-high and EES diminished the sexual behavior of male fish, accompanied with reduced E2 levels in the brain and the expression of genes in the kisspeptin/gonadotropin-releasing hormone system. Interestingly, the sexual behavior of unexposed females paired with treated males was also reduced, indicating a synergistic effect. This study suggests that EES have a more severe impact on reproduction than EE2-low, and EEs could interfere not only with spermatogenesis in fish, but also with the sexual behaviors of both exposed males and their female partners, thereby leading to a more significant disruption in fish reproduction.
环境雌激素(EEs)在天然水体中广泛存在,对鱼类繁殖产生负面影响。关于环境相关浓度下EEs混合物对鱼类生殖毒性的研究较少。在本研究中,成年雄性斑马鱼分别暴露于EES(一种EEs混合物)、低剂量EE2(5.55纳克/升,雌激素效力等同于EES)和高剂量EE2(11.1纳克/升)60天。暴露后,EES处理组鱼肝脏中vtg1、vtg3和esr1的表达水平未发生改变,而EE2处理组鱼的这些基因表达显著增加。高剂量EE2和EES暴露均显著降低了性腺指数和精子数量。在高剂量EE2和EES暴露的鱼的睾丸中还观察到精子发生紊乱,同时与精原细胞增殖(pcna、nanog)、细胞周期转换(cyclinb1、cyclind1)和减数分裂(aldh1a2、cyp26a1、sycp3)相关的基因表达也发生了改变。EE2和EES均显著降低了雄性鱼血浆中11 - 酮睾酮水平,可能是通过抑制其合成相关基因(scc、cyp17a1和cyp11b2)的表达实现的,并且升高了17β - 雌二醇(E2)水平,可能是通过上调cyp19a1a的表达。高剂量EE2和EES处理的雄性鱼中tnfrsf1a表达及tnfrsf1a/tnfrsf1b比值显著增加,这也表明通过外源性途径凋亡增加。进一步研究表明,高剂量EE2和EES均降低了雄性鱼的性行为,同时伴随着脑中E2水平降低以及吻肽/促性腺激素释放激素系统中基因表达的改变。有趣的是,未暴露的雌性鱼与处理过的雄性鱼配对时,其性行为也降低了,表明存在协同效应。本研究表明,EES对繁殖的影响比低剂量EE2更严重,EEs不仅会干扰鱼类的精子发生,还会影响暴露雄性及其雌性配偶的性行为,从而对鱼类繁殖造成更显著的破坏。