School of Social Sciences, Education & Social Work, 6. College Park, Queen's University Belfast, UK.
School of Social Sciences, Education & Social Work, 6. College Park, Queen's University Belfast, UK.
Int J Law Psychiatry. 2024 Jul-Aug;95:102005. doi: 10.1016/j.ijlp.2024.102005. Epub 2024 Jul 3.
Social Support has multiple benefits for health and mental wellbeing. Its existence, and the extent to which it can be beneficial, is dependent upon the context in which it is provided, and the recipients' view of it. Social support has long been established as a 'buffer' to the negative impact of stressful life experiences. Trauma can negatively impact upon social support, reducing the extent of social networks and ability of some trauma experienced individuals to sustain extensive social support networks. However, some trauma experiences can also strengthen social relationships. Imprisoned men are disproportionately likely to have experienced a traumatic event when compared with the general population. Past research has found that traumatic events can lead to a decrease in social support among imprisoned men but more research is needed to understand the variations in perceived social support experienced by imprisoned men and to determine how different types of trauma may be related to perceived social support.
A cross-sectional survey of 384 adult men detained in the Northern Ireland Prison Service was conducted between November 2022 and January 2023. The survey collected data on the men's demographics, mental health, substance use, and criminal history. Respondents were also asked to complete a Trauma History Questionnaire (THQ) and the Multi-dimensional Scale of Perceived Social Support (MSPSS). Regression analysis was then used to investigate the possible associations between individual characteristics, different types of trauma experiences and perceived social support.
Most types of trauma experiences were not associated with lower levels of perceived social support. Only those who had experienced crime related trauma were more likely to report lower levels of social support. Older imprisoned men and those using substances were more likely to report lower levels of perceived social support, while those who had served a sentence of less than one year reported higher levels of perceived social support.
Crime related trauma experiences were found to be associated with lower levels of perceived social support. There were no significant findings around perceived social support and any of the other trauma types i.e. physical, sexual and general disaster experiences. Trauma informed policy responses should be cognisant of this, as those with experiences of crime related victimisation are less likely to have the social support needed to buffer against future trauma experiences. The findings demonstrate that some individuals experience lower levels of perceived social support and several factors are associated with this including age, time served and substance use history. This will potentially impact upon them during release and affect their reintegration into society. Specific policies aimed at these groups should be considered to prevent them from experiencing a lack of support and any accompanying adversity upon release.
社会支持对健康和心理健康有多种益处。它的存在及其有益程度取决于提供的背景以及接受者对它的看法。社会支持长期以来一直被认为是减轻生活压力经历负面影响的“缓冲器”。创伤会对社会支持产生负面影响,减少社交网络的范围,并使一些经历创伤的人难以维持广泛的社会支持网络。然而,一些创伤经历也可以加强人际关系。与普通人群相比,被监禁的男性更有可能经历创伤事件。过去的研究发现,创伤事件会导致被监禁的男性的社会支持减少,但需要更多的研究来了解被监禁的男性所经历的感知社会支持的变化,并确定不同类型的创伤与感知社会支持之间的关系。
2022 年 11 月至 2023 年 1 月期间,对北爱尔兰监狱管理局关押的 384 名成年男性进行了横断面调查。该调查收集了男性人口统计学、心理健康、药物使用和犯罪史的数据。受访者还被要求完成创伤史问卷 (THQ) 和多维感知社会支持量表 (MSPSS)。然后使用回归分析来研究个体特征、不同类型的创伤经历和感知社会支持之间的可能关联。
大多数类型的创伤经历与感知社会支持水平较低无关。只有那些经历过与犯罪相关的创伤的人更有可能报告社会支持水平较低。年龄较大的被监禁男性和使用药物的人更有可能报告感知社会支持水平较低,而那些被判不到一年徒刑的人报告的感知社会支持水平较高。
与犯罪相关的创伤经历与感知社会支持水平较低有关。在感知社会支持和任何其他类型的创伤(即身体、性和一般灾难经历)之间没有发现显著的关联。具有犯罪相关受害经历的人不太可能获得缓冲未来创伤经历所需的社会支持,因此,基于创伤的政策应对措施应该认识到这一点。研究结果表明,一些人感知社会支持水平较低,几个因素与这一点有关,包括年龄、服刑时间和药物使用史。这可能会对他们在获释期间产生影响,并影响他们重新融入社会。应考虑针对这些群体的具体政策,以防止他们在获释时缺乏支持和任何伴随的逆境。