Caniglia Ellen C, Zash Rebecca, Diseko Modiegi, Mayondi Gloria, Mabuta Judith, Mmalane Mompati, Makhema Joseph, Jacobson Denise L, Bengtson Angela M, Lockman Shahin, Shapiro Roger, Swanson Sonja A
Department of Biostatistics, Epidemiology, and Informatics, University of Pennsylvania Perelman School of Medicine, Philadelphia, USA.
Botswana Harvard Health Partnership, Gaborone, Botswana.
Am J Epidemiol. 2025 Jan 8;194(1):122-131. doi: 10.1093/aje/kwae160.
Women and other people of childbearing potential living with HIV (WLHIV) have a higher risk of adverse birth outcomes than those without HIV (WWHIV). A higher risk of anemia in WLHIV could partially explain this disparity. Using a birth outcomes surveillance study in Botswana, we emulated target trials corresponding to currently available or feasible interventions on anemia. The first target trial evaluated 2 interventions: initiate multiple micronutrient supplementation (MMS), and MMS or iron and folic acid supplementation by 24 weeks gestation. The remaining target trials evaluated the interventions: eliminate anemia before pregnancy; and jointly eliminate anemia before pregnancy and initiate MMS. We estimated the observed disparity in adverse birth outcomes between WLHIV and WWHIV and compared the observed disparity measure (ODM) to the counterfactual disparity measure (CDM) under each intervention. Of 137 499 individuals (22% WLHIV), the observed risk of any adverse birth outcome was 26.0% in WWHIV and 34.5% in WLHIV (ODM, 8.5%; 95% confidence interval [CI], 7.9-9.1%). Counterfactual disparity measures (95% CIs) ranged from 6.6% (4.8-8.4%) for the intervention to eliminate anemia and initiate MMS to 8.4% (7.7%-9.1%) for the intervention to eliminate anemia only. Preventing anemia and expanding MMS may reduce HIV disparities in birth outcomes, but interventions with greater impact should be identified.
感染艾滋病毒的育龄妇女(WLHIV)比未感染艾滋病毒的妇女(WWHIV)出现不良分娩结局的风险更高。WLHIV患贫血症的风险较高可能部分解释了这种差异。利用博茨瓦纳的一项出生结局监测研究,我们模拟了与目前可用或可行的贫血干预措施相对应的目标试验。第一个目标试验评估了2种干预措施:开始补充多种微量营养素(MMS),以及在妊娠24周前补充MMS或铁和叶酸。其余目标试验评估了以下干预措施:在怀孕前消除贫血;以及在怀孕前联合消除贫血并开始补充MMS。我们估计了WLHIV和WWHIV在不良分娩结局方面观察到的差异,并将观察到的差异测量值(ODM)与每种干预措施下的反事实差异测量值(CDM)进行了比较。在137499名个体(22%为WLHIV)中,WWHIV中观察到的任何不良分娩结局的风险为26.0%,WLHIV中为34.5%(ODM,8.5%;95%置信区间[CI],7.9 - 9.1%)。反事实差异测量值(95%CI)范围从消除贫血并开始补充MMS的干预措施的6.6%(4.8 - 8.4%)到仅消除贫血的干预措施的8.4%(7.7% - 9.1%)。预防贫血和扩大MMS补充可能会减少艾滋病毒在分娩结局方面的差异,但应确定具有更大影响的干预措施。