Tappen N C
Am J Phys Anthropol. 1985 May;67(1):43-50. doi: 10.1002/ajpa.1330670106.
It has been suggested that the fossil Neandertal from La Chapelle-aux-Saints was so toothless that he would have had to have his food pre-chewed or otherwise prepared for him. This has also led to the inference that a high level of altruistic social behavior was characteristic of Neandertals. This appears to be in keeping with a current trend among anthropologists to upgrade the cultural and evolutionary status of Neandertals. Close examination of the recovered teeth and the condition of the alveoli indicates that the "old man" of La Chapelle-aux-Saints had upper and lower incisor, canine and premolar teeth on the left side intact and probably in occlusion, and that the same was true of these teeth in the right maxilla. Mandibular incisors, canine, and first premolar had probably been lost to a tumor or abscessing on the right side, but this pathology may have developed near the time of death. The right mandibular second premolar was probably functional, although tilted similarly to the intact premolar on the left. It is very unlikely that the individual was unable to chew food. The dentition thus gives no reliable evidence of altruistic behavior by his cohorts. This study may also relate to hypotheses concerning the ancestry of anatomically modern humans.
有人提出,来自圣沙拜尔的尼安德特人化石牙齿脱落严重,以至于他不得不让人预先咀嚼食物或为他准备好其他食物。这也导致了一种推断,即高度利他的社会行为是尼安德特人的特征。这似乎与人类学家目前提升尼安德特人文化和进化地位的趋势相一致。对找回的牙齿和牙槽状况的仔细检查表明,圣沙拜尔的“老人”左侧的上下切牙、犬齿和前磨牙完好无损,可能处于咬合状态,右侧上颌的这些牙齿也是如此。下颌切牙、犬齿和第一前磨牙可能因右侧的肿瘤或脓肿而缺失,但这种病变可能在接近死亡时才出现。右侧下颌第二前磨牙可能仍有功能,尽管其倾斜方式与左侧完好的前磨牙相似。这个人不太可能无法咀嚼食物。因此,牙齿状况并不能为其同伴的利他行为提供可靠证据。这项研究也可能与有关解剖学上现代人类祖先的假说有关。