Psychol Trauma. 2024 Dec;16(Suppl 3):S722. doi: 10.1037/tra0001730. Epub 2024 Jul 25.
Reports an error in "Ayahuasca in the treatment of posttraumatic stress disorder: Mixed-methods case series evaluation in military combat veterans" by Brandon Weiss, Lê-Anh L. Dinh-Williams, Nick Beller, Ian M. Raugh, Gregory P. Strauss and William K. Campbell (, Advanced Online Publication, Dec 07, 2023, np). In the original article, there was an error in the calculations that led to the overstatement of the symptom severity of the veteran sample. Specifically, sum scores for the posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) symptom checklist (PCL-5) were scored using a 1-5 Likert scale rather than the appropriate 0-4 Likert scale. As a result, although it was stated that participants in the veteran sample exhibited clinical levels of PTSD based on the >33 PCL-5 threshold associated with a PTSD diagnosis, the levels actually reflected moderate posttraumatic stress symptoms. In addition, estimates of significantly reliable change in PCL-5 scores after an ayahuasca intervention (from 87.5% to 71.4%) were modified, and the threshold criteria for clinically significant changes (posttreatment scores <28) were removed because several participants met these criteria at baseline, thus impacting the interpretation of treatment outcomes. (The following abstract of the original article appeared in record 2024-34611-001).
Although ayahuasca-a plant-based psychedelic-is discussed as promising in the treatment of posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD), evidence so far remains limited to retrospective case reports and qualitative surveys. No study to date has examined whether ayahuasca results in prospective and clinically meaningful changes in trauma symptoms across individuals with PTSD symptoms.
To address this gap, we conducted a convergent mixed-methods case series study on eight military veterans with PTSD who participated in a 3-day ayahuasca intervention in Central America. Clinically meaningful changes from pre- to posttreatment and at a 3-month follow-up were assessed in three ways using: (a) PTSD checklist-5 (PCL-5); (b) experience sampling measurement of momentary PTSD and mood symptoms; and (c) an open-ended survey on perceived benefits.
The majority (87.5%; 7/8) of participants demonstrated reliable and/or clinically significant changes in PCL-5 symptoms by posttreatment, which were maintained by 70% (5/7) of veterans by the 3-month follow-up. On average, veterans also reported significant improvements in momentary PTSD symptoms, as well as negative and positive affect in daily life posttreatment, with 63% (5/8) reporting moderate-to-large improvements in these domains. Broad themes characterizing the perceived benefits of ayahuasca included deep positive emotions, decentering/acceptance, and purpose in life; adverse acute experiences were, however, reported.
This study provides preliminary support for the clinically meaningful and lasting benefits of a brief ayahuasca intervention on PTSD/mood symptoms in military veterans. (PsycInfo Database Record (c) 2024 APA, all rights reserved).
布兰登·韦斯、黎安·L·丁-威廉姆斯、尼克·贝勒、伊恩·M·劳、格雷戈里·P·施特劳斯和威廉·K·坎贝尔所著的《死藤水治疗创伤后应激障碍:军事战斗退伍军人的混合方法病例系列评估》(2023年12月7日高级在线发表,无页码)报告了一处错误。在原文中,计算存在错误,导致退伍军人样本的症状严重程度被高估。具体而言,创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)症状清单(PCL-5)的总分是使用1-5李克特量表评分而不是合适的0-4李克特量表。因此,尽管文中称退伍军人样本中的参与者基于与PTSD诊断相关的PCL-5阈值>33表现出临床水平的PTSD,但实际水平反映的是中度创伤后应激症状。此外,对死藤水干预后PCL-5评分的显著可靠变化估计(从87.5%至71.4%)进行了修正,并且去除了临床显著变化的阈值标准(治疗后得分<28),因为有几位参与者在基线时就达到了这些标准,从而影响了对治疗结果的解释。(原始文章的以下摘要出现在记录2024-34611-001中)
尽管死藤水这种基于植物的迷幻剂在治疗创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)方面被认为有前景,但迄今为止的证据仅限于回顾性病例报告和定性调查。迄今为止,尚无研究考察死藤水是否会导致有PTSD症状的个体在创伤症状方面出现前瞻性且具有临床意义的变化。
为填补这一空白,我们对八名患有PTSD的军事退伍军人进行了一项收敛性混合方法病例系列研究,这些退伍军人在中美洲参加了为期三天的死藤水干预。使用以下三种方式评估从治疗前到治疗后以及在3个月随访时具有临床意义的变化:(a)创伤后应激障碍清单-5(PCL-5);(b)对瞬间PTSD和情绪症状的经验抽样测量;以及(c)关于感知益处的开放式调查。
大多数(87.5%;7/8)参与者在治疗后PCL-5症状出现了可靠和/或具有临床意义的变化,到3个月随访时,70%(5/7)的退伍军人保持了这些变化。平均而言,退伍军人还报告说瞬间PTSD症状以及治疗后日常生活中的消极和积极情绪有显著改善,63%(5/8)的人报告在这些方面有中度至大幅改善。描述死藤水感知益处的广泛主题包括深刻的积极情绪、去中心化/接纳和生活目的;然而,也报告了不良的急性体验。
本研究为短期死藤水干预对军事退伍军人的PTSD/情绪症状具有临床意义且持久的益处提供了初步支持。(PsycInfo数据库记录(c)2024美国心理学会,保留所有权利)