Khalaf Mai A, Ayoub Fares, Staggers Kristen A, El-Haj Johanna W, Jawaid Salmaan, Othman Mohamed O
Gastroenterology, Baylor College of Medicine, Houston, United States.
Tropical Medicine and infectious diseases, Tanta University Faculty of Medicine, Tanta, Egypt.
Endosc Int Open. 2024 Jul 25;12(7):E905-E913. doi: 10.1055/a-2337-3865. eCollection 2024 Jul.
Endoscopic submucosal dissection (ESD) allows removal of tumors en-bloc. Western adoption of ESD has been hindered by its steep learning curve. Western data regarding ESD learning curve are limited. We analyzed the learning curve of a single endoscopist at a tertiary referral center in the United States. All consecutive ESDs performed by a single endoscopist at a tertiary referral center in the United States from 2015 through 2022 were identified. Descriptive statistics and CUSUM analysis were used to describe the learning curve for en-bloc, R0 resection, and resection speed. In our study, 503 patients with 515 lesions were included. Severe submucosal fibrosis was found in 17% of the lesions. The rates of en-bloc, R0, and curative resections were 81.9%, 71.1%, and 68.4%, respectively. CUSUM analysis showed that the learning curve plateaued at 268, 347, and 170 cases for en-bloc resection, R0 resection, and achieving a resection speed > 9 cm /hr. Fibrosis significantly affected the R0 resection rate in the regression analysis (95% confidence interval 0.21-0.55). In colonic ESD curve analysis, the learning plateau was reached after 185 cases for both en-bloc and R0 resection. Following ex-vivo training in an animal model, an untutored expert operator achieved competency in ESD between 250 and 350 procedures. Our data can inform development of future training programs in the West.
内镜黏膜下剥离术(ESD)可完整切除肿瘤。ESD在西方的应用受到其陡峭学习曲线的阻碍。西方关于ESD学习曲线的数据有限。我们分析了美国一家三级转诊中心一名内镜医师的学习曲线。确定了该内镜医师于2015年至2022年在美国一家三级转诊中心连续进行的所有ESD手术。采用描述性统计和累积和分析(CUSUM分析)来描述完整切除、R0切除及切除速度的学习曲线。在我们的研究中,纳入了503例患者的515个病变。17%的病变发现有严重黏膜下纤维化。完整切除、R0切除和根治性切除率分别为81.9%、71.1%和68.4%。CUSUM分析显示,完整切除、R0切除以及切除速度>9 cm/hr的学习曲线分别在268例、347例和170例时趋于平稳。在回归分析中,纤维化显著影响R0切除率(95%置信区间0.21 - 0.55)。在结肠ESD曲线分析中,完整切除和R0切除在185例后均达到学习平稳期。在动物模型中进行体外训练后,一名未经指导的专家操作员在250至350例手术之间掌握了ESD技能。我们的数据可为西方未来培训项目的开展提供参考。