Beck Christian, Lazarovici Dustin
Humanities and Arts Department, Technion-Israel Institute of Technology, Haifa 3200003, Israel.
Entropy (Basel). 2024 Jun 27;26(7):548. doi: 10.3390/e26070548.
What guarantees the "peaceful coexistence" of quantum nonlocality and special relativity? The tension arises because entanglement leads to locally inexplicable correlations between distant events that have no absolute temporal order in relativistic spacetime. This paper identifies a relativistic consistency condition that is weaker than Bell locality but stronger than the no-signaling condition meant to exclude superluminal communication. While justifications for the no-signaling condition often rely on anthropocentric arguments, relativistic consistency is simply the requirement that joint outcome distributions for spacelike separated measurements (or measurement-like processes) must be independent of their temporal order. This is necessary to obtain consistent statistical predictions across different Lorentz frames. We first consider ideal quantum measurements, derive the relevant consistency condition on the level of probability distributions, and show that it implies no-signaling (but not vice versa). We then extend the results to general quantum operations and derive corresponding operator conditions. This will allow us to clarify the relationships between relativistic consistency, no-signaling, and local commutativity. We argue that relativistic consistency is the basic physical principle that ensures the compatibility of quantum statistics and relativistic spacetime structure, while no-signaling and local commutativity can be justified on this basis.
是什么保证了量子非定域性与狭义相对论的“和平共处”?这种矛盾的产生是因为纠缠导致了在相对论时空中没有绝对时间顺序的远距离事件之间存在局部无法解释的关联。本文确定了一个相对论一致性条件,它比贝尔局域性弱,但比旨在排除超光速通信的无信号条件强。虽然对无信号条件的论证通常依赖于以人类为中心的观点,但相对论一致性仅仅是要求类空分离测量(或类似测量的过程)的联合结果分布必须与其时间顺序无关。这对于在不同洛伦兹参考系中获得一致的统计预测是必要的。我们首先考虑理想量子测量,在概率分布层面推导相关的一致性条件,并表明它意味着无信号(反之不成立)。然后我们将结果扩展到一般量子操作,并推导相应的算符条件。这将使我们能够阐明相对论一致性、无信号和局域对易性之间的关系。我们认为相对论一致性是确保量子统计与相对论时空结构兼容性的基本物理原理,而无信号和局域对易性可以在此基础上得到论证。