Wagner Bernhard, Toro Juan Manuel, Mayayo Ferran, Hoeschele Marisa
Austrian Academy of Sciences, Acoustics Research Institute, Vienna 1040, Austria.
Passeig de Lluís Companys, Institució Catalana de Recerca i Estudis Avançats (ICREA), Barcelona 08010, Spain.
R Soc Open Sci. 2024 May 29;11(5):221181. doi: 10.1098/rsos.221181. eCollection 2024 May.
Octave equivalence describes the perception that two notes separated by a doubling in frequency have a similar quality. In humans, octave equivalence is important to both music and language learning and is found cross-culturally. Cross-species studies comparing human and non-human animals can help illuminate the necessary pre-conditions to developing octave equivalence. Here, we tested whether rats () perceive octave equivalence using a standardized cross-species paradigm. This allowed us to disentangle concurring hypotheses regarding the evolutionary roots of this phenomenon. One hypothesis is that octave equivalence is directly connected to vocal learning, but this hypothesis is only partially supported by data. According to another hypothesis, the harmonic structure of mammalian vocalizations may be more important. If rats perceive octave equivalence, this would support the importance of vocal harmonic structure. If rats do not perceive octave equivalence, this would suggest that octave equivalence evolved independently in several mammalian clades due to a more complex interplay of different factors such as-but not exclusively-the ability to vocally learn. Evidence from our study suggests that rats do perceive octave equivalence, thereby suggesting that the harmonic vocal structure found in mammals may be a key pre-requisite for octave equivalence. Stage 1 approved protocol: the study reported here was originally accepted as a Registered Report and the study design was approved in Stage 1. We hereby confirm that the completed experiment(s) have been executed and analysed in the manner originally approved with any unforeseen changes in those approved methods and analyses clearly noted. The approved Stage 1 protocol can be found at: https://osf.io/gvf7c/?view_only=76dc1840f31c4f9ab59eb93cbadb98b7.
频率翻倍的两个音符具有相似的音质。在人类中,八度等效性对音乐和语言学习都很重要,并且在不同文化中都有发现。比较人类和非人类动物的跨物种研究有助于阐明形成八度等效性的必要前提条件。在这里,我们使用标准化的跨物种范式测试了大鼠是否感知八度等效性。这使我们能够梳理关于这一现象进化根源的同时存在的假设。一种假设是八度等效性与发声学习直接相关,但这一假设仅得到部分数据的支持。根据另一种假设,哺乳动物发声的谐波结构可能更重要。如果大鼠感知八度等效性,这将支持发声谐波结构的重要性。如果大鼠不感知八度等效性,这将表明八度等效性在几个哺乳动物类群中是独立进化的,这是由于不同因素(但不仅限于)如发声学习能力等更复杂的相互作用。我们研究的证据表明大鼠确实感知八度等效性,从而表明哺乳动物中发现的谐波发声结构可能是八度等效性的关键先决条件。第一阶段批准的方案:此处报告的研究最初被接受为注册报告,研究设计在第一阶段获得批准。我们在此确认已按照最初批准的方式执行并分析了完整的实验(如有),并清楚地记录了那些批准方法和分析中任何不可预见的变化。批准的第一阶段方案可在以下网址找到:https://osf.io/gvf7c/?view_only=76dc1840f31c4f9ab59eb93cbadb98b7 。