College of Environmental Science and Engineering, North China Electric Power University, Beijing 102206, China.
J Hazard Mater. 2024 Sep 15;477:135371. doi: 10.1016/j.jhazmat.2024.135371. Epub 2024 Jul 29.
Salicylic esters (SEs), the widely used ultraviolet (UV) absorbers in sunscreen products, have been found to have health risks such as skin sensitization and estrogenic effects. This study aims to design SE substitutes that maintain high UV absorbance while reducing estrogenicity. Using molecular docking and Gaussian09 software for initial assessments and further application of a combination of two-dimensional and three-dimensional quantitative structure-activity relationships (2D-QSAR and 3D-QSAR, respectively) models, we designed 73 substitutes. The best-performing molecules, ethylhexyl salicylate (EHS)-5 and EHS-15, significantly reduced estrogenicity (44.54 % and 17.60 %, respectively) and enhanced UV absorbance (249.56 % and 46.94 %, respectively). Through screening for human health risks, we found that EHS-5 and EHS-15 were free from skin sensitivity and eye irritation and exhibited reduced skin permeability compared with EHS. Furthermore, the photolysis and synthetic pathways of EHS-5 and EHS-15 were deduced, demonstrating their good photodegradability and potential synthesizability. In addition, we analyzed the mechanisms underlying the changes in estrogenic effects and UV absorption properties. We identified covalent hydrogen bond basicity and acidity Propgen value for atomic molecular properties and the highest occupied molecular orbital eigenvalue as the main factors affecting the estrogenic effect and UV absorbance of SEs, respectively. This study focuses on the design and screening of SEs, exhibiting enhanced functionality, reduced health risks, and synthetic feasibility.
水杨酸酯(SEs)作为防晒霜中常用的紫外线(UV)吸收剂,已被发现存在健康风险,如皮肤致敏和雌激素效应。本研究旨在设计 SE 的替代品,在保持高紫外线吸收的同时降低雌激素活性。本研究使用分子对接和 Gaussian09 软件进行初步评估,并进一步应用二维和三维定量构效关系(2D-QSAR 和 3D-QSAR)模型的组合,设计了 73 种替代品。表现最好的分子,即乙基己基水杨酸酯(EHS)-5 和 EHS-15,显著降低了雌激素活性(分别为 44.54%和 17.60%),并提高了紫外线吸收(分别为 249.56%和 46.94%)。通过筛选人类健康风险,我们发现 EHS-5 和 EHS-15 没有皮肤敏感性和眼睛刺激性,并且与 EHS 相比,皮肤通透性降低。此外,推断了 EHS-5 和 EHS-15 的光解和合成途径,表明它们具有良好的光降解性和潜在的可合成性。此外,我们分析了雌激素效应和紫外线吸收性质变化的机制。我们确定了共价氢键碱性和酸性 Propgen 值作为原子分子性质的主要因素,以及最高占据分子轨道本征值作为影响 SEs 雌激素效应和紫外线吸收的主要因素。本研究重点研究了 SEs 的设计和筛选,展示了增强的功能、降低的健康风险和合成可行性。