Brown University, Department of Sociology, Providence, RI, 02912, USA.
University of South Carolina, Department of Health Services Policy and Management, Columbia, SC, 29208, USA.
Soc Sci Med. 2024 Sep;356:117161. doi: 10.1016/j.socscimed.2024.117161. Epub 2024 Jul 26.
Relatively few neighborhood-focused studies explicitly model the relationship between neighborhood change- i.e., racial change within a neighborhood-and individual mental health, instead focusing on the current composition of the neighborhood or on the outcomes of individuals that switch neighborhood contexts via moves. Further, while neighborhoods and schools are interconnected, researchers tend to focus on only one of these contexts in their work. Combining family and student data from the Panel Study of Income Dynamics (PSID) with multiple waves of neighborhood and school administrative data, our study extends current scholarship in this area by explicitly focusing on the relationship between exposure to neighborhood and school racial change-i.e., change occurring within the neighborhood or school in the prior decade-and the behavior problems of current students. We further analyze how associations vary: 1) by student race; 2) between newcomers to the neighborhood and those that lived in the neighborhood as it underwent demographic change; 3) and in neighborhoods with higher proportions of same-race residents. Our findings suggest that the relationship between local neighborhood contexts and the behavioral problems of children is nuanced and depends on the racial trajectories-change or stability-of neighborhoods, schools, and the interaction of both. Compared to longer-term residents, White newcomers tended to have more behavioral problems across racially changing and stable neighborhoods alike, regardless of the racial trajectories observed in the local school. Our results align with past work documenting the protective effect of same-race peers for Black children. Conversely, we find White students exhibit greater behavioral problems in settings with very high proportions of same-race peers, particularly in neighborhoods and schools that are simultaneously becoming increasingly racially isolated.
相对较少的以社区为重点的研究明确地将社区变化的关系——即社区内的种族变化——与个体心理健康联系起来,而是专注于当前社区的组成,或者关注通过搬家改变社区环境的个体的结果。此外,尽管社区和学校是相互关联的,但研究人员在他们的工作中往往只关注这些环境中的一个。我们的研究结合了来自收入动态面板研究(PSID)的家庭和学生数据以及多波次的社区和学校行政数据,通过明确关注社区和学校种族变化的暴露程度与当前学生行为问题之间的关系,扩展了该领域的现有学术研究。我们进一步分析了关联如何变化:1)根据学生的种族;2)在社区经历人口变化之前居住在社区的新来者与那些居住在社区的人之间;3)以及在同种族居民比例较高的社区中。我们的研究结果表明,地方社区环境与儿童行为问题之间的关系是复杂的,取决于社区、学校以及两者相互作用的种族轨迹——变化或稳定。与长期居住者相比,无论当地学校观察到的种族轨迹如何,新来的白人往往在种族变化和稳定的社区中都有更多的行为问题。我们的研究结果与过去的研究工作一致,这些研究工作记录了同种族同伴对黑人儿童的保护作用。相反,我们发现,在同种族比例非常高的环境中,白人学生表现出更多的行为问题,特别是在同时变得越来越种族隔离的社区和学校。