Rinnooy Kan Willemijn F, Munniksma Anke, Volman Monique, Dijkstra Anne Bert
Department of Child Development and Education, University of Amsterdam, Amsterdam, the Netherlands.
Res Pap Educ. 2023 Mar 2;39(4):560-580. doi: 10.1080/02671522.2023.2178496. eCollection 2024.
The abilities of citizens to make themselves heard and listen to each other are essential for the functioning of democratic societies. Schools are practice grounds for these citizenship competences. This study investigates whether students' experiences with voice in school are related to their attitudes towards voice (contributing and listening democratically), and how a democratic school culture affects this relation. Overall, 5297 students, from 240 classrooms, in 81 Dutch secondary schools, participated in the study. Results of multilevel analyses revealed that students' voice experiences at school, their own and those of their classmates, are positively related to students' attitudes towards contributing and listening democratically. This relation is not affected by a democratic school culture. These findings underline the relevance of opportunities to practice voice at school for all students and of the social nature of practicing voice. More generally, this study illustrates the importance of understanding schools as practice grounds for citizenship.
公民表达自身意见并相互倾听的能力对于民主社会的运转至关重要。学校是培养这些公民素养的实践场所。本研究调查了学生在学校的发声体验是否与他们对发声(民主地表达和倾听)的态度相关,以及民主的学校文化如何影响这种关系。总体而言,来自荷兰81所中学240个班级的5297名学生参与了这项研究。多层次分析结果显示,学生在学校的发声体验,包括他们自己的以及同学的发声体验,与学生对民主表达和倾听的态度呈正相关。这种关系不受民主学校文化的影响。这些发现强调了学校为所有学生提供发声实践机会的重要性以及发声实践的社会性。更广泛地说,本研究说明了将学校理解为公民素养实践场所的重要性。