Vieyres C, Roblot P, Grignon B, Charles-Gervais C, Becq-Giraudon B
Pathol Biol (Paris). 1985 Jun;33(5 Pt 2):586-90.
The value of serum bactericidal activity (SBA) determination for assessing the effectiveness of antibiotic therapy was evaluated in a retrospective open study in 168 cases of septicemia. Outcomes in a first group (I) of 67 patients with a SBA of at least 1/4 were compared with outcomes in a second group (II) of 101 patients with a SBA below 1/4 or non-determined. Within these groups, outcomes of 37 septicemias due to Gram negative bacilli (subgroup Ia) and 22 staphylococcal septicemias (subgroup Ib) with a SBA greater than or equal to 1/4 were compared with outcomes in 26 septicemias due to Gram negative bacilli (subgroup IIa) and 22 staphylococcal septicemias (subgroup IIb) with a SBA less than 1/4. Statistical analysis of distribution of age, sex, underlying disease, biologic parameters and antibiotics given demonstrated no significant difference between the various groups. 56 patients (86.1%) recovered in group I, against 76 (79.1%) in group II; corresponding figures are 34 (91.1%) and 21 (84%) in subgroups Ia and IIa respectively. These differences are not significant (p greater than 0.05). Our findings suggest that an "effective" SBA fails to correlate with favorable outcome of septicemia.
在一项针对168例败血症患者的回顾性开放性研究中,评估了血清杀菌活性(SBA)测定对于评估抗生素治疗效果的价值。将67例SBA至少为1/4的患者分为第一组(I组),并与101例SBA低于1/4或未测定的患者分为的第二组(II组)的结果进行比较。在这些组中,将37例由革兰氏阴性杆菌引起的败血症(Ia亚组)和22例SBA大于或等于1/4的葡萄球菌败血症(Ib亚组)的结果,与26例由革兰氏阴性杆菌引起的败血症(IIa亚组)和22例SBA小于1/4的葡萄球菌败血症(IIb亚组)的结果进行比较。对年龄、性别、基础疾病、生物学参数和所用抗生素的分布进行统计分析表明,各组之间无显著差异。I组56例患者(86.1%)康复,II组为76例(79.1%);Ia亚组和IIa亚组的相应数字分别为34例(91.1%)和21例(84%)。这些差异无统计学意义(p>0.05)。我们的研究结果表明,“有效”的SBA与败血症的良好预后无关。