Nunez Cesar Vargas
Claremont McKenna College.
J Health Polit Policy Law. 2025 Feb 1;50(1):1-21. doi: 10.1215/03616878-11513062.
Most of the 11 million undocumented immigrants living in the United States are excluded from government health care programs. Yet, health care inequities pose significant dangers to all members of society during a pandemic. This project explores to what extent undocumented immigrants, in the context of a pandemic, can be seen as deserving of access to government health care programs.
The project's first survey experiment explores whether work ethic can affect perceptions of undocumented immigrants as deserving of government health care programs. The second survey experiment tests to what extent appeals to fairness and self-interest, during a pandemic, shape health care deservingness attitudes.
The results show that respondents view undocumented immigrants as less deserving of health care than citizens, even when undocumented immigrants have a solid work history. The second survey experiment, however, shows that appeals to fairness and self-interest trigger substantial increases in support for undocumented immigrants among both Republicans and Democrats.
The results suggest that while undocumented immigrants are seen as less deserving of access, appeals to fairness and self-interest can trigger increased support.
生活在美国的1100万无证移民大多被排除在政府医疗保健项目之外。然而,在疫情期间,医疗保健不平等对社会所有成员都构成了重大危险。本项目探讨在疫情背景下,无证移民在何种程度上可被视为应获得政府医疗保健项目。
该项目的首个调查实验探讨职业道德是否会影响对无证移民应获得政府医疗保健项目的看法。第二个调查实验测试在疫情期间,对公平和自身利益的诉求在多大程度上塑造了对医疗保健应得性的态度。
结果表明,即使无证移民有稳定的工作经历,受访者仍认为他们比公民更不应获得医疗保健。然而,第二个调查实验表明,对公平和自身利益的诉求促使共和党人和民主党人对无证移民的支持大幅增加。
结果表明,虽然无证移民被视为较不应获得医疗保健,但对公平和自身利益的诉求可引发更多支持。