Burrow Rebecca
University of Tennessee Knoxville, Knoxville, TN, USA
Instructor of Nursing University of Tennessee Health Science Center, Community and Population Health, Memphis, TN, USA.
Res Theory Nurs Pract. 2024 Aug 14. doi: 10.1891/RTNP-2023-0127.
Perinatal loss is a tremendous loss for many and can have consequences that affect physical and mental health. This topic has been substantially examined among women; however, men's experiences with perinatal loss have lacked attention. Many men report significant grief, self-blame, stigma, loss of self-identity, lack of recognition of their loss, marginalization, and gendered expectations that negate their grieving process. This places men at risk for complicated or disenfranchised grief. Most studies examining perinatal loss have been conducted in countries outside of the United States and outside of the discipline of nursing. As nurses are concerned about holistic care of men and women, the findings resulting from studies with women and other cultural perspectives may not be generalizable to men in the United States. The purpose of this integrative review was to examine the current state of science regarding men's experiences with perinatal loss, what is known about this loss within the nursing discipline, to identify gaps in nursing knowledge, and to expose areas for further research. Online databases including CINAHL, PubMed, and Scopus were used to perform the initial search. The search terms included "men," "perinatal loss," "miscarriage," "stillbirth," and "grief." Themes were identified through a review of the literature that included that men experienced a loss of the role of fatherhood and identity. Additionally, men reported expectations about socially and gender-specific behavior that influenced their expressions of grief and their coping process. Finally, the lack of recognition of their loss as fathers in perinatal loss resulted in the marginalization and the use of avoidance and distraction to cope with the loss, as well as risks to the health of the partnered relationship.
围产期丧子对许多人来说是巨大的损失,可能会产生影响身心健康的后果。这个话题在女性中已经得到了充分研究;然而,男性在围产期丧子方面的经历却未受到关注。许多男性报告称有巨大的悲痛、自责、耻辱感、自我认同丧失、丧子之痛未得到认可、被边缘化以及性别期望否定了他们的悲痛过程。这使男性面临复杂或被剥夺权利的悲痛风险。大多数关于围产期丧子的研究是在美国以外的国家以及护理学科以外进行的。由于护士关注男性和女性的整体护理,来自对女性及其他文化视角研究的结果可能无法推广到美国的男性身上。本整合性综述的目的是研究关于男性围产期丧子经历的科学现状、护理学科内对这种丧子之痛的了解、确定护理知识的空白,并揭示进一步研究的领域。使用包括护理学与健康领域数据库(CINAHL)、医学期刊数据库(PubMed)和Scopus在内的在线数据库进行初步搜索。搜索词包括“男性”“围产期丧子”“流产”“死产”和“悲痛”。通过对文献的综述确定了一些主题,包括男性经历了父亲角色和身份的丧失。此外,男性报告称社会和性别特定行为的期望影响了他们的悲痛表达和应对过程。最后,在围产期丧子中作为父亲的丧子之痛未得到认可,导致他们被边缘化,并采用回避和转移注意力的方式来应对丧子之痛,同时也给伴侣关系的健康带来风险。