McGraw Christopher Michael, Poduri Annapurna
Department of Neurology, Massachusetts General Hospital, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA 02115, USA.
Department of Neurology, The F.M. Kirby Neurobiology Center, Boston Children's Hospital, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA 02115, USA.
bioRxiv. 2024 Aug 5:2024.08.01.606228. doi: 10.1101/2024.08.01.606228.
Identifying new, more efficacious anti-seizure medications (ASMs) is challenging, partly due to limitations in animal-based assays. Zebrafish () can serve as a model of chemical and genetic seizures, but methods for detecting seizure-like activity in zebrafish, though powerful, have been hampered by low sensitivity (locomotor/behavioral assays) or low-throughput (tectal electrophysiology or calcium fluorescence microscopy). To address these issues, we developed a novel approach to assay seizure-like activity using combined locomotor and calcium fluorescence features, measured simultaneously from unrestrained larval zebrafish using a 96-well fluorescent plate reader. Using custom software to track fish movement and changes in fluorescence (deltaF/F0) from high-speed time-series (12.6Hz), we trained logistic classifiers using elastic net regression to distinguish seizure-like activity from non-seizure related changes based on event-specific and subject-specific features in response to the GABAR antagonist, pentylenetetrazole (PTZ). We demonstrate that a classifier trained on combined movement and fluorescence data achieves high accuracy ("PTZ M+F"; area-under-curve receiver-operator characteristic (AUC-ROC): 0.98; F1 score: 0.912) and out-performs classifiers trained on movement ("PTZ M"; AUC-ROC: 0.9, F1: 0.9) or fluorescence features alone ("PTZ F"; AUC-ROC 0.96; F1: 0.87). The rate of classified seizure-like events increases as a dose-response to PTZ (serial dose escalation, 0, 2.5mM, 15mM) and is strongly suppressed by ASM treatment (valproic acid, VPA; tiagabine, TGB). At high-dose PTZ, we show that VPA reduces seizure-like activity defined by either "PTZ M+F" or "PTZ M" classifiers. Meanwhile, TGB selectively reduces events defined by the "PTZ M+F" classifier, paralleling previous reports that TGB reduces electrographic but not locomotor seizures and highlighting the potential for our approach to combine features of previously orthogonal assays. Using ASM benchmark data, we employ bootstrap simulation to calculate the expected statistical power of our method as a function of sample size. We demonstrate that anti-seizure responses (robust strictly standardized mean difference, RSSMD, versus control) with magnitudes similar to those associated with VPA or TGB can be reliably detected (true positive rate (TPR) > 90%) with as few as N=4 biological replicates per group, while maintaining a 5% false positive rate. In a prospective test screen with 3-6 replicates per group and on-plate controls, the anti-seizure effect of 4 out of 5 tested ASMs (CBZ, LEV, LZP, TGB) was detected. In summary, we demonstrate a simple high-throughput approach to whole organism anti-seizure phenotyping combining two previously reported metrics to facilitate screens for novel anti-seizure interventions in zebrafish.
识别新型、更有效的抗癫痫药物(ASMs)具有挑战性,部分原因是基于动物的检测方法存在局限性。斑马鱼(Danio rerio)可作为化学性和遗传性癫痫发作的模型,但检测斑马鱼癫痫样活动的方法虽强大,却因灵敏度低(运动/行为检测)或通量低(顶盖电生理学或钙荧光显微镜检查)而受到阻碍。为解决这些问题,我们开发了一种新方法,利用运动和钙荧光特征组合来检测癫痫样活动,使用96孔荧光酶标仪从不受约束的斑马鱼幼体中同时测量这些特征。通过定制软件跟踪鱼类运动以及高速时间序列(12.6Hz)下荧光的变化(ΔF/F0),我们使用弹性网络回归训练逻辑分类器,根据对GABAA拮抗剂戊四氮(PTZ)的反应中特定事件和特定个体的特征,将癫痫样活动与非癫痫相关变化区分开来。我们证明,在运动和荧光数据组合上训练的分类器具有高精度(“PTZ M+F”;曲线下面积接受者操作特征(AUC-ROC):0.98;F1分数:0.912),并且优于仅在运动(“PTZ M”;AUC-ROC:0.9,F1:0.9)或荧光特征(“PTZ F”;AUC-ROC 0.96;F1:0.87)上训练的分类器。分类的癫痫样事件发生率随PTZ剂量反应增加(系列剂量递增,0、2.5mM、15mM),并被ASM治疗(丙戊酸,VPA;噻加宾,TGB)强烈抑制。在高剂量PTZ下,我们表明VPA可降低由“PTZ M+F”或“PTZ M”分类器定义的癫痫样活动。同时,TGB选择性降低由“PTZ M+F”分类器定义的事件,这与之前关于TGB减少脑电图癫痫发作但不减少运动性癫痫发作的报道一致,并突出了我们的方法结合先前正交检测特征的潜力。使用ASM基准数据,我们采用自助模拟来计算我们方法作为样本量函数的预期统计功效。我们证明,与VPA或TGB相关的抗癫痫反应(稳健的严格标准化平均差异,RSSMD,与对照相比),每组仅需N = 4个生物学重复即可可靠检测(真阳性率(TPR)> 90%),同时保持5%的假阳性率。在每组有3 - 6个重复和板上对照的前瞻性测试筛选中,检测到了5种测试ASM中的4种(卡马西平,CBZ;左乙拉西坦,LEV;拉考沙胺,LZP;噻加宾,TGB)的抗癫痫作用。总之,我们展示了一种简单的高通量方法,用于全生物体抗癫痫表型分析,结合了两个先前报道的指标,以促进对斑马鱼新型抗癫痫干预措施的筛选。