Auma Erick, Alberts Rencia, Derendinger Brigitta, Venter Rouxjeane, Streicher Elizabeth M, Pillay Samantha, Ghebrekristos Yonas T, Mburu Moses, Ruhwald Morten, Warren Robin, Penn-Nicholson Adam, Theron Grant, de Vos Margaretha
DSI-NRF Centre of Excellence for Biomedical Tuberculosis Research, SAMRC Centre for Molecular and Cellular Biology, Division of Molecular Biology and Human Genetics, Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences, Stellenbosch University, Cape Town, South Africa.
National Health Laboratory Service, Greenpoint Tuberculosis Laboratory, Cape Town, South Africa.
Res Sq. 2024 Sep 4:rs.3.rs-4841978. doi: 10.21203/rs.3.rs-4841978/v2.
Drug susceptibility testing (DST) is essential for effectively starting people on effective tuberculosis (TB) regimens. No accuracy data exists for the new high-throughput LiquidArray MTB-XDR (LA-XDR) test, which detects complex (MTBC) and susceptibility to the fluoroquinolones, amikacin, ethambutol, and linezolid (the latter two drugs have no rapid molecular DSTs available). We enrolled (n=720) people with presumptive TB who provided two sputa for Xpert MTB/RIF Ultra and culture (MTBC reference standard). Phenotypic DST and Sanger sequencing served as a composite reference standard. Manual FluoroLyse and automated GenoXtract-fleXT (fleXT) DNA extraction methods were compared. For MTBC, LA-XDR using fleXT-extracted or FluoroLyse-extracted DNA had similar sensitivities (85-87%; which improved upon eluate retesting) and specificities (99%). Drug susceptibility sensitivities varied: 94% (86, 98) for fluoroquinolones, 64% (45, 80) for amikacin, and 88% (79, 93) for ethambutol (specificities 97-100%). LA-XDR detected 86% (6/7) phenotypically resistant linezolid isolates. LA-XDR with fleXT had indeterminate proportions of 8% (21/251) for fluoroquinolones, 1% (2/251) for ethambutol, 25% (63/251) for amikacin, and 37% (93/251) for linezolid. In a hypothetical population of 100 smear-negative fluoroquinolones-resistant cases, 24% (24/100) could be missed due to an unsuccessful result (1 fleXT error and, for LA-XDR, 2 invalid results, 15 MTBC-negative, 6 fluoroquinolone-indeterminate, 1 false-susceptible). LA-XDR met the minimum WHO target product profile for a next-generation sputum-based moderate complexity DST with high sensitivity for fluoroquinolones and ethambutol resistance, moderate sensitivity for amikacin resistance, and promise for linezolid resistance, for which more data are needed. Improved MTBC detection would reduce missed resistance.
药物敏感性测试(DST)对于有效地让患者开始使用有效的结核病(TB)治疗方案至关重要。新型高通量LiquidArray MTB-XDR(LA-XDR)检测方法不存在准确性数据,该检测方法可检测复合分枝杆菌(MTBC)以及对氟喹诺酮类、阿米卡星、乙胺丁醇和利奈唑胺(后两种药物尚无快速分子DST方法)的敏感性。我们纳入了720例疑似结核病患者,他们提供了两份痰液用于Xpert MTB/RIF Ultra检测和培养(MTBC参考标准)。表型DST和桑格测序用作复合参考标准。比较了手动FluoroLyse和自动GenoXtract-fleXT(fleXT)DNA提取方法。对于MTBC,使用fleXT提取或FluoroLyse提取的DNA进行LA-XDR检测,其敏感性相似(85%-87%;洗脱液重新检测后有所提高),特异性为99%。药物敏感性各不相同:氟喹诺酮类为94%(86,98),阿米卡星为64%(45,80),乙胺丁醇为88%(79,93)(特异性为97%-100%)。LA-XDR检测出86%(6/7)表型耐药的利奈唑胺分离株。使用fleXT进行LA-XDR检测时,氟喹诺酮类的不确定比例为8%(21/251),乙胺丁醇为1%(2/251),阿米卡星为25%(63/251),利奈唑胺为37%(93/251)。在假设的100例涂片阴性且对氟喹诺酮类耐药的病例群体中,由于检测结果不成功(1次fleXT错误,对于LA-XDR,2次无效结果,15次MTBC阴性,6次氟喹诺酮类不确定,1次假敏感),24%(24/100)的病例可能会被漏检。LA-XDR符合世界卫生组织下一代基于痰液的中等复杂度DST的最低目标产品概况,对氟喹诺酮类和乙胺丁醇耐药具有高敏感性,对阿米卡星耐药具有中等敏感性,对利奈唑胺耐药有前景,但还需要更多数据。改进MTBC检测将减少耐药漏检。