Boise State University, ID, USA.
Old Dominion University, Norfolk, VA, USA.
Trauma Violence Abuse. 2024 Dec;25(5):4045-4061. doi: 10.1177/15248380241270083. Epub 2024 Aug 16.
Intimate partner violence (IPV), inclusive of all forms of abuse, is an ongoing public health and criminal-legal issue that transcends social boundaries. However, there is a lack of equitable representation of diverse populations who experience IPV in the literature. To garner a holistic knowledge of diverse IPV survivor populations' experiences with seeking help from the police, the current review utilized a qualitative research synthesis methodology to explore police interactions among six IPV survivor populations that are underrepresented in the current literature: women with substance use issues, immigrant women, women in rural localities, heterosexual men, racially/ethnically minoritized women, and sexual minority women. Seven electronic databases were searched to identify peer-reviewed articles on IPV survivors' narrative descriptions (qualitative or mixed-methods) of their encounters with law enforcement. The final analysis included 28 studies that were then coded with an iterative coding strategy. The analysis uncovered the following themes: (a) revictimization by the police, (b) police negligence, (c) discrimination, (d) cultural differences, and (e) positive experiences. These themes demonstrated that while some experiences with law enforcement were shared between under-researched survivor groups, some experiences were explicitly tied to some aspects of survivors' identities. Recognizing the potential law enforcement has to support survivors, the findings of the current review reiterate the need for ongoing efforts to improve law enforcement knowledge and overall response to IPV, especially for diverse populations of IPV survivors.
亲密伴侣暴力(IPV),包括所有形式的虐待,是一个持续存在的公共卫生和刑事法律问题,超越了社会界限。然而,在文献中,经历 IPV 的不同人群的代表性不足。为了全面了解不同 IPV 幸存者群体寻求警察帮助的经历,本综述采用定性研究综合方法,探讨了在当前文献中代表性不足的六种 IPV 幸存者群体与警察的互动:有药物使用问题的妇女、移民妇女、农村地区的妇女、异性恋男性、种族/族裔少数化的妇女和性少数妇女。搜索了七个电子数据库,以确定关于 IPV 幸存者对与执法部门相遇的叙述描述(定性或混合方法)的同行评审文章。最终分析包括 28 项研究,然后采用迭代编码策略对其进行编码。分析揭示了以下主题:(a)警察的再次受害,(b)警察的疏忽,(c)歧视,(d)文化差异,以及(e)积极的体验。这些主题表明,虽然一些与执法部门的经历在研究不足的幸存者群体之间是共有的,但一些经历与幸存者身份的某些方面明确相关。认识到执法部门有可能支持幸存者,本综述的研究结果重申了需要不断努力提高执法部门的知识和对 IPV 的整体反应,特别是针对 IPV 幸存者的不同人群。