Ford M R
Biofeedback Self Regul. 1985 Sep;10(3):223-39. doi: 10.1007/BF00999344.
Although the data base describing clinical outcome following biofeedback/relaxation training is accumulating, there have been relatively few attempts to predict short-term outcome, and even fewer for long-term outcome. Significant short-term outcome predictors have been identified, and they often allude to the level of psychological distress as a major factor affecting outcome. To investigate further the role of psychological variables in outcome prediction, this project presents preliminary findings that demonstrate the relationship involving interpersonal psychological stress, interpersonal style of behavior, and outcome. With a very heterogeneous group of patients (N = 39), measures of interpersonal style of behavior were used to discriminate correctly 80% of cases by outcome at the 3-month postadmission evaluation. With a more homogeneous group having somatic disorders alone (headache, Raynaud's, etc.), the accuracy of prediction at 3 months was 90%. No measures were capable of predicting long-term outcome with accuracies even moderately greater than chance. The results indicate that style of interpersonal behavior (e.g., managerial, dependent) and, to a lesser extent, interpersonal stress is predictive of short-term outcome following biofeedback/relaxation training. Individuals who tend to like responsibility and who are more executive and independent generally benefited more than doubtful, obedient, and depressed individuals. While the resulting prediction rates were only slightly more accurate than MMPI D and Pt subscales alone, the procedures provide additional information regarding the personality characteristics of successful and unsuccessful biofeedback clients, and may also provide the clinician with information regarding treatment choice if biofeedback is provided as an adjunct to psychotherapy.
尽管描述生物反馈/放松训练后临床结果的数据库正在不断积累,但预测短期结果的尝试相对较少,预测长期结果的尝试则更少。已确定了显著的短期结果预测因素,它们常常暗示心理困扰程度是影响结果的一个主要因素。为了进一步研究心理变量在结果预测中的作用,本项目展示了初步研究结果,这些结果证明了人际心理压力、人际行为风格与结果之间的关系。对于一组非常异质的患者(N = 39),人际行为风格的测量在入院后3个月的评估中能够根据结果正确区分80%的病例。对于一组仅患有躯体疾病(如头痛、雷诺氏病等)的更同质的患者,3个月时的预测准确率为90%。没有任何测量方法能够以比随机概率显著更高的准确率预测长期结果。结果表明,人际行为风格(例如,掌控型、依赖型)以及在较小程度上的人际压力可预测生物反馈/放松训练后的短期结果。倾向于喜欢承担责任、更具执行力和独立性的个体通常比心存疑虑、顺从和沮丧的个体受益更多。虽然由此得出的预测率仅比单独使用明尼苏达多相人格调查表(MMPI)的抑郁(D)和精神衰弱(Pt)分量表略准确一些,但这些程序提供了关于成功和不成功的生物反馈治疗对象人格特征的额外信息,并且如果将生物反馈作为心理治疗的辅助手段,还可能为临床医生提供有关治疗选择的信息。