Kamarunas Erin, Murray Kelsey, Drulia Teresa, Szynkiewicz Sarah, Griffin Lindsay, Mulheren Rachel
Department of Communication Sciences and Disorders, James Madison University, 235 MLK Jr. Way, MSC 4304, Harrisonburg, VA, 22807, USA.
Davies School of Communication Sciences and Disorders, Texas Christian University, Fort Worth, TX, USA.
Dysphagia. 2025 Apr;40(2):489-500. doi: 10.1007/s00455-024-10751-w. Epub 2024 Aug 18.
Rehabilitative exercises require precise movement coordination and target accuracy for optimal effectiveness. This paper explores the impact of tongue strength exercises (TSE) performance accuracy on exercise outcomes, adherence, and participant confidence and motivation. An 8-week randomized clinical trial included 84 typically aging participants divided into four groups defined by access to biofeedback (present/absent) and TSE intensity dosing (maximal/submaximal) during a home exercise program (HEP). Retention, training, and HEP accuracy were tracked at biweekly visits and during HEP for participants with access to a biofeedback device. Associations with tongue strength outcomes, participant factors, biofeedback, and intensity dosing were analyzed. Exercise accuracy measures did not contribute to tongue strength outcomes at the end of 8 weeks. Increased training accuracy (less practice required to achieve competency) was associated with higher participant confidence and better adherence to the HEP. The presence of biofeedback was associated with reduced adherence but better retention accuracy, while maximal intensity was associated with improvements in all accuracy measures compared to submaximal intensity exercise. These findings in typically aging participants suggest the need for tailored approaches in swallowing-related exercise programs, given the effects of biofeedback and exercise intensity on motor learning and exercise retention. Accuracy performance and its effect on clinical outcomes warrants study in clinical populations with dysphagia and with various rehabilitative approaches.Trial Registration Clincialtrials.gov: NCT04809558.
康复训练需要精确的动作协调和目标准确性才能达到最佳效果。本文探讨了舌肌力量训练(TSE)的执行准确性对训练效果、依从性以及参与者信心和动机的影响。一项为期8周的随机临床试验纳入了84名正常衰老的参与者,他们被分为四组,这四组是根据在家庭锻炼计划(HEP)中是否可获得生物反馈(有/无)以及TSE强度剂量(最大/次最大)来定义的。对于可使用生物反馈设备的参与者,在每两周的随访以及HEP期间跟踪其保持情况、训练情况和HEP准确性。分析了与舌肌力量结果、参与者因素、生物反馈和强度剂量之间的关联。在8周结束时,锻炼准确性指标对舌肌力量结果没有贡献。训练准确性的提高(达到能力所需的练习次数减少)与参与者更高的信心以及对HEP更好的依从性相关。生物反馈的存在与依从性降低但保持准确性更好相关,而与次最大强度锻炼相比,最大强度与所有准确性指标的改善相关。这些在正常衰老参与者中的发现表明,鉴于生物反馈和锻炼强度对运动学习和锻炼保持的影响,在吞咽相关的锻炼计划中需要采用量身定制的方法。准确性表现及其对临床结果的影响值得在吞咽困难的临床人群以及各种康复方法中进行研究。试验注册Clinicaltrials.gov:NCT04809558。